Recent content by Hussar

Nope, I was 100% wrong. For some reason I never realized that it was always a force bubble. Totally my bad. But, rereading the spell, I do notice that it doesn't block attacks.

Oh, you're right. I had totally forgotten that Leo's Hut was a force effect. Been too long. I guess my point is, so few of those spells ever saw any actual play. Either they were too high level, rather pointless (unseen servant was something I used personally, but, never, ever saw anyone...

Not even sure if we can blame Gygax for this one to be honest. Magic Missile wasn't a "force" effect in OD&D. It was an actual arrow. It was a "magical missile" in AD&D. It wasn't until 5e that it suddenly became a bolt of force. Shield was always a "force" effect, even if it wasn't called...

Thing is though, we already have that - magic damage. It's what weapons do to bypass resistances. So, why give wizards yet another way to be more effective? Just change "force" to "magic" and we're good to go. Then remove all the "force area" effect spells like Forcecage and Leo's Hut and...

Well, the problem is that it gets added to so much. Why does an artificer's construct deal force damage with a bite? Well, mechanically that's so it bypasses any damage resistance. But, it makes zero sense. And, really, what is "force" damage? A mace deals force damage but we call it...

This is kind of the point I was trying to make. The reason that this has all these bizarre interpretations (does it have a floor, how do you breathe, what happens if you use it under water? etc.) is because they insist on using these "force" rules. Just make it a cottage and all of a sudden...

If the atmosphere is "comfortable and dry", being filled with fire, smoke or poisonous gas is not what I would call comfortable and dry. Well, I suppose fire breath might make you really, really dry. :D If it keeps rain and snow out, why wouldn't it keep out things like fire and smoke? Up to...

I mean, yeah, that would be fine at 3rd level or maybe even 2nd level really. It's a small house. Perfect. It does what it's supposed to do - be a place to shelter from the elements while you rest. It's defensible, but, not invulnerable. I would have no problems with this spell at all...

Heh. Troglodytes. Or, better yet, Kuo-Toa so that they can actually bring about a god. :D But, the point is well made. LTH is a 5th level spell. It comes into the game pretty early. It's not hard to have 5th and 6th level parties with this. And, the enemies that 5th and 6th level parties...

Yes, that would be correct - one group for 3 campaigns - a homebrew Spelljammer campaign, a Candlekeep Mysteries campaign and ... I'm actually blanking on the third one. Might have been 2 campaigns. ;) My point being, it was VERY player dependent. I've since rotated out a bunch of different...

Well, you weren't talking about me either, so, I guess that's fair. On the idea of a hemisphere doesn't have a straight line. A hemisphere without a "bottom" isn't a hemisphere. It's an arc. If we want to get all technical and all. Considering every other version of LTH that is a hemisphere...

Sorry, where did I say "every group"? I said the last group I had. My current group doesn't. But, thanks for the assumption that it was my own incompetence that was the issue. Of course it could never possibly be that 5e has made casters so much better than non-casters and, frankly, made...

No, they can't. It's a hemisphere and it has a floor. That's been clarified in 2024 because now it's an emanation which means it extends as a sphere. Granted, it's blocked by the ground, which makes it a hemi-sphere. So, no, they cannot come through the floor. Again, nope. the atmosphere...

See, kind of caster is going to matter too. Druid can't cast Hut. Warlock probably won't have it unless he's a tomelok. Now, Bard and Wizard can have it, so, it might come up. Again, like I said, if you've never had a player who started abusing it, it's hard to see how it would be a problem...

Honestly, I think it's like a lot of things in the game. If you've never seen it used, you don't really realize just how disruptive it can be. But, once you've been on the receiving end of players abusing Hut to the most they possible can, it gets really easy to fall into the trap of thinking...