Recent content by John Lloyd1

  1. J

    Hasbro CEO Reiterates That AI Isn't Used to Make D&D Because of the Game's Audience and Creators

    I can't understand the value of a backstory generator. I sometimes imagine LLM AI as a version of the electric monk from the the Dirk Gentry series. But instead of watching the video we have recorded on our VCR for us, it expands our thoughts into large documents that it then summarises for us...
  2. J

    Ironsworn Actual Play

    I have a copy of Starforged on order. Keep checking the distributor website to see if it is in Australia yet.
  3. J

    Pumpkin Spice Joins the Million Dollar Crowdfunder Club

    I wonder how much this is 'art drives game' like Tales in the Loop. It seems to be re-using art by SimzArt.
  4. J

    D&D 5E (2024) D&D 2024 Is Now OFFICIALLY Called "5.5e"

    It would seem that if you were communicating with potential buyers, you would need to take in consideration some of your buyers would only have seen the physical books and some only DND Beyond. They may not be hooked into the online D&D community and wouldn't know about the other terminology...
  5. J

    D&D 5E (2024) D&D 2024 Is Now OFFICIALLY Called "5.5e"

    They had an official label. It was 2024. Now they have all these books in print that refer to 2024 versions and a website referring to 5.5. I think they are making a mess.
  6. J

    D&D 5E (2024) D&D Beyond's Development Roadmap Is A Complete Rebuild Of Platform

    I prefer 5e to refer to the whole family of games including A5e and ToV. If you are just talking about the 5e produced by Wotc, it is D&D 5e. to specify a particular version, 5e 2014 or 2024. Or you could say D&D 5e (2024). It can be ambiguous if 5.5 refers to ToCE or 2024 and 6e refers to 2024...
  7. J

    Let's talk about "plot", "story", and "play to find out."

    Maybe we should be using a literature definition of 'story', but rather a history definition of story. I.e. connected events, etc to to create meaning.
  8. J

    Vincent Baker on narrativist RPGing, then and now

    How many sessions do you think can done before the systems run out of headroom? Or is that a nonsensical question?
  9. J

    Vincent Baker on narrativist RPGing, then and now

    Do we have examples of games built using narrativism that would work for beer and pretzel players? Would Monster of the Week be one?
  10. J

    How do you define "Heartbreaker?"

    I do think that creator feelings and expectations is also part of the mix. If you just through a product out there without an expectation that it will be appreciated, then your heart can't be broken even if nobody takes an interest. Both creator investment and a lack of community response are...
  11. J

    How do you define "Heartbreaker?"

    I have a hard time seeing an electrum best seller as a heartbreaker. It seems to me a key part of the definition from Edwards and common usage is the devastating lack of interest from the rpg community. I.e it sinks without a trace.
  12. J

    Tell me about the RPG section of your local game store

    I suspect they just don't do anything other than distribution. They are a chain of game franchise stores.
  13. J

    Tell me about the RPG section of your local game store

    Buying directly from the publisher usually comes at a huge cost when you are in Australia. I bought physical copies of 3 Sly Flourish books and paid the same again in postage. They weren't available in distribution locally or I would have bought them through my FLGS. I usually prefer to use my...
  14. J

    D&D 5E (2024) Online Treasure Generators for D&D 2024 Recommendations

    Treasure generators are more functional if the source materials are already freely available online. :)
Top