Mannahnin's latest activity

I thought the same, but after digging into Daggerheart a bit, I think its actually more OSR, than 5e is. Bad DMing for sure. Have you...

OP wants to play trad 1.5E/2E. Yeah, Shadowdark won’t be a good fit for that. The End.

I can't say how you personally used to play TSR D&D. But OSE (Basic) for example is literally a cleaned up port of D&D B/X. So when...

Or human to get an extra talent roll!

The Facebook Shadowdark group is full of people who have not touched an RPG since 1984 who are in love with Shadowdark. I would be...

You're conflating bad design and not being financially successful. I don't deny SD's popularity or financial success. However, I do...

No dude, this is false its honestly not that hard at all.

Last night, I finished Lorne: The Man Who Invented Saturday Night Live by Susan Morrison. It's kind of a fascinating book, equally a...

Certainly Your Table May Vary territory. At the tables I sat at, demi-humans were never allowed to use this both by virtue of the RAW...

The two revisions in weapon specialization are in PHBR1 The Complete Fighter's Handbook page 58: "Only single-class warriors (fighters...

2e specialization actually made picking up random new magic weapons more feasible for fighters than 1e did. In 2e you could specialize...

Shrug. I guess our philosophy was "if you're a MU is in melee at level 1, you're screwed anyway so might as well have something useful...

Potentially available, you could have friends as your random 1st level offensive spell instead. :) Thieves and MUs are actually one...

They are two different weapons so to use both types yes, two different proficiencies. Just like dagger and knife once you get the...

With eleven classes in the PH and multiple races with various multiclass and level limits to pick from I felt 1e pre-UA had a bunch of...