Maxperson's latest activity

Yeah. The only place I disagree with you on this is from your former post where you say that you think most people treat D&D combat as...

Causality gets broken routinely - as in my example, A gets to duck behind cover at the end of their 6 seconds of action, and that...

Combat in d&d is an exception to the normal game loop and the combat loop is well known to produce implausible results. It’s a strong...

It still was written to DMs. 1) you can't assume that all players are on there and aren't using the physical books, 2) just because it...

@pemerton is mostly right in his view on this. The initiative process produces ridiculous results if you look at things happening...

They actually tell the DM that, not the players. The quote is in the DMG, not the PHB. And the way the wrote is was reminiscent of bad...

The Forge went belly-up what 20 years ago? And you still think it's relevant? People argued about the terms back then, it hasn't gotten...

Fail forward does not have to lead to success at the task in some manner. It just means that failure will still result in the story...

Why would you assume hunting and foraging in a game where food and water can be created and rations purchased. Those things are not...

It's a wonderful house, very quiet with tons of room. It's a very old house, built in 1896 and modified in pieces over the decades...

I have friends who were in the bloody things. Imagine how they felt, after being used like that.

The key part of that post seems to me "you can't go off into the trees to look for herbs the way we can". Retconning is different, for...

You aren't being told it doesn't work. You're being told that it's very different. The only thing about your posts that I said didn't...