RenleyRenfield's latest activity

In my mind, "generative" has always meant that the narrative decision is informed by a chart or a table or a deck of cards. Something...

I think, maybe dunno yet, the mistake is is the initial assumption that any of this is discreate or that there is a model at all...

This is a fun point, I would be interested in how each of these plays into and plays out generative and positional gameplay (each...

See below... I am not saying I disagree with much said by anyone here. But from these two statements i can clearly say = Pasion de las...

We just finished 2 years, 2 trilogy's, in our Star Wars rpg system, I vote us. :D Aside from us, I would vote Cortex prime, but that...

Indeed! One thing we found with my RPG was that it has a LOT of spells the players can choose from and even possibly use starting game...

@RenleyRenfield Also, I really like the point you made about how soon after chargen a rule will matter. I recognize that my system...

Ohh this is near and dear to my heart! I heard someone describe two similar games, same core system, yet why one came across as...

Out of ...sheesh... 130 backed kickstarter/backerkit RPG/Boardgames.... I have only had 3 that I was not happy with the end product...

Yeah, pretty much. The whole concept is a bit fuzzy, so don't worry about not knowing exactly what's being asked, that's kind of the point.

Indeed, that is very much what I was thinking in that regard. So ... I still am not sure the question this thread is asking. Ideas...

I think the place to start is, as the GM, to set generative consequences as part of adjudication before the player rolls. That doesn't...

This is also what I am wondering too... So I Fail a persuasion check, that reads RaW = nothing. you failed. There is no result of a...

This gets to part of what I am not understanding about @pemerton question in this post. All of all of what all of everyone has said...

To me it is perfectly clear that what is happing in any RPG play is story creation. This goes for trad games where players merely...