Recent content by UngeheuerLich

Why bring it up then? So until now, everything is fine. Let's hope it stays that way.

Why should it? It has been mire than 10 years now. Utilizing the battlefield was a strength of 4e. With all the upsides and downsides. I understood the title immediately.

Good analogy. Would you run your car over a cliff or would you know about an invisible something if you were told that? Also just an interpretation. Wouldn't you open your garage to get the car out? Oh. I would actually not allow that, as those actions don't help you get away. Neither would I...

Not for me, not for you. We had one if we ever sat at the same table.

Because the cliff is not invisivle... As I said. Can't help you. You clearly don't want to see the problem.

Yeah. What I said. Yeah. And the enchantment will have them bump against the wall. Yeah. I see that you are not seeing it. So whatever.

Also: level 5 has revivify. So maybe the assassination should have been successful and on a target when the pary splits. So maybe have them beeing followed for a while. And at some points a perception check or survival check could have given them some clues.

You however want it to divine an invisible wall. Which is not what the spell can do. See above. You say the magic guides the receipient around an invisible wall. Which is not something an enchantment should do.

Totally ok. No one died, but it was tense. Giving enemies species encounters is fair game to me and should have been the advice in the MM or DMG to begin with.

Already discussed at length. In my games magic, is not allmighty. And an enchantment spell is no divination spell.

I do not speak about power. I speak about the implications.

Why not drop?

Which is quite nonsense if you compare this level 1 spell to spells which are way higher in level.

AI is good at spitting out ideas. It still takes humans to evaluate it and refine it. At some point AI will be a too as every other one.

I'd just allow it as a free object interaction. But that is just a ruling, so no RAW to back it up. Maybe you could give enemies advantage on attack rolls against the shield wearer instead of -shield bonus, because it still protects but is dangling around annyoingly. Maybe a cleaner solution...