reapersaurus said:
2 discussion topics for you all:
1) Did anyone have any concerns about using FR stuff, etc when the only Pantheon clockwork has for this game is Olympic gods?
(I guess that one's mostly for cleric-type characters : What did you all use for domains? Did it make sense to have your character teleported in just now, but make them worshipers of the gods?)
I was somewhat curious about favored weapons, but I figured it wouldn't be that difficult to map domains between similar deities and such. The only problem would be alignment issues. Although you could probably find a Greek god with the right domain, it might not have a similar alignment. For example, you might only be able to get Retribution from an evil or chaotic diety, instead of from Tyr, making things tough for the cleric/paladin.
2) Isn't this GoD kind of expected to use a 'smackdown'ish character?
What _I_ mean by smackdown is a character that can put some hurting on somebody. (I'm not using some alternate definition that others have been that defines it as a one trick pony)
Should characters be well built and constructed so that they might reasonably expect to win? Yes. So far, we've seen even a bard dish out decent damage. I'd imagine that most characters, when in their element, pose a significant threat. Tobias's attacks haven't impressed me much, but I'd expect that when any character cuts lose, the person on the recieving end won't be happy unless they have special defenses. However, I think the game would be rather boring if most characters could do enough damage to kill just about anyone in one attack sequence. It's not very much fun to die before being able to do something.
My problem with OA isn't the power level. FR has overpowered magic stuff. OA has overpowered melee stuff. However, if I only expect overpowered FR magic when I make my character, but not the super melee from OA, then my character probably has some holes in his defenses. Since clockworkjoe said that he posted his invitation for players on other boards, you can't expect everyone to have read your comments about using OA. However, I think it was pretty decent of you to ask publicly, and not in private email, so that at least some people were aware of it.
Also, I don't really see why anyone should be asking for special exceptions. I can see some modifications and such - there are always grey areas that require adjunctation. For example, because of psi-magic transparency, psions are effectively pure caster classes. Therefore, I can see how a psion might become a lich. I'd have prefer it if the regular lich template had the entry requirements modified slightly to allow for psions, but oh well. However, you can make a dangerous shield charge guy without any extra stuff. In fact, without OA, your character wouldn't have to look silly by fighting with 2 shields.