FrogReaver
The most respectful and polite poster ever
I find the case for Carnap more compelling than the case for goodberry
D&D 5E Does Rope Trick Heal?
- Thread starter FrogReaver
- Start date
I find the case for Carnap more compelling than the case for goodberry
W
WhosDaDungeonMaster
Guest
This thread has become a car wreck for me... I see it has new posts and I HAVE TO READ them! ARG! 
FrogReaver
The most respectful and polite poster ever
This thread has become a car wreck for me... I see it has new posts and I HAVE TO READ them! ARG!
I’m still waiting for my thank you.
This thread has become a car wreck for me... I see it has new posts and I HAVE TO READ them! ARG!
Of course it became a car wreck, Frog cast Carnap and the cars fell asleep, presumably while driving.
FarBeyondC
Explorer
Last I checked, Catnip doesn't give you hit dice to spend. So, if you don't have any hit dice to spend before said spell is cast on you, you can't heal.
In my opinion at least, something only counts as a healing spell if all the resources (actions are not a resource in this case) required for the healing to occur are provided by the spell itself.
Going back to the OP:
Though the spell can certainly enable healing, I would not say that rope trick- on its own- heals.
not-so-newguy
Legend
Blue
Ravenous Bugblatter Beast of Traal
Eating berry created by Goodberry spell or drinking a healing potion: directly heal.
Casting the goodberry spell to create berries: Does not directly heal.
Nope, not anything like each other.
You're the one who brought up "direct" as a criteria, how can a spell that doesn't target a creature and doesn't heal on casting be "direct".
Last edited:
Eespecially when the Oasis is barren.If it makes a difference. I'm done answering these two. You can lead horses to water, but you can't make them directly drink.
Similar Threads
- Poll
