Search results

  1. Silent Cartographer

    How To Kill An Adult Black Dragon Without Dying Of Boredom

    Maybe big stand-off fights with bosses like this could provide an ideal opening for, oh.., say, negotiation? Just askin'! ;) That was the problem with 5 round kill or be killed fights; there was never enough time or motivation for well-matched opponents to seriously consider any other...
  2. Silent Cartographer

    Plano/Dallas - Looking for 4E D&D Group

    40-something professional looking to get out from behind the DM's screen for a while. I've been running games off and on for 30 years (D&D, Traveller, Shadowrun, etc.). My usual group is on hold indefinitely due to work schedule conflicts. Plus, I would really like to try 4th edition from the...
  3. Silent Cartographer

    Your role? Nothing matters but combat.

    I very much doubt that this is the original Bugaboo of fame and legend. The classic Bugaboo was a true artiste, and I doubt would stoop to such elementary material. I guess the alias became available again; I haven't been aware of the original Bugaboo posting for several years.
  4. Silent Cartographer

    The Rouse at The eXPerience

    Pink Pony: "I'm a MONSTAR! Rowr!" :p
  5. Silent Cartographer

    Why won't you switch?

    Best non-news 4th edition discussion thread in several weeks!!! ;) You guys rock! Seriously. :cool: That may not be a very high bar, but despite inevitable bits of silly posturing and needless scab picking, the signal survived for a good many pages. Thanks! I won't switch this spring...
  6. Silent Cartographer

    What's so Hard About Grappling?

    As far as I am concerned, the 3E grapple rules are complete ass. I'm quite comfortable with this view, as the only people who really count in my game, my players, all agree and have let me know on a regular basis (for several years now) just how assy grappling is. This is despite the fact that...
  7. Silent Cartographer

    What classes will be in the martial power book?

    I agree that this book may not contain any new classes. It looks to me like Rogue is the new base swashing class, rather than Fighter. I definitely see the Swashbuckler as a martial striker with some secondary control powers. I always just assumed that the Monk would be a martial controller...
  8. Silent Cartographer

    The Possibility of "Too Fantastic" Fantasy

    The furry law of roleplay dynamics? ;)
  9. Silent Cartographer

    The Death of Simulation

    Since I'm going on some very old memories for 1E AD&D rules, I'm quite willing to stand corrected on that score; your knowledge of 1E is clearly fresher than mine. I agree with your final conclusion; that's a good analysis. In any case, the point was that 4E has changed design direction in...
  10. Silent Cartographer

    The Death of Simulation

    Nail, meet hammer, heheh... ;) I agree that 4E is going to upset a lot of closet simulationists this spring. The design architecture for 4E clearly a vision of gamist flexibility and power, and supports narrative play mainly through the abstraction provided by that architecture. That same...
  11. Silent Cartographer

    D&D 4E 4E Worlds: what are my options? What are you going to do?

    Muchas Gracias for the West Marches link! :cool:
  12. Silent Cartographer

    D&D 4E 4e Gold Rush: What 3rd Party Support Do You Expect?

    I mis-understood the poll, and voted on what I wanted (expectation of need), rather than try to second guess the marketplace. I'll feel a lot more confident about 3rd party high-level content after 5 months than before... While I'm leaning towards 4E optimism, my current 3.5 campaign won't...
  13. Silent Cartographer

    Rich Baker on the Points of Light Setting.

    I like it. It's like a pinewood derby for newbie GMs, and everyone can publish their version on the web (gleemax, etc.). When I started out, drawing the map was half the fun of homebrewing; this setting-kit setup allows beginners to put their own stamp on their campaigns without excessive...
  14. Silent Cartographer

    The Tielfling and The Gnome: On the Set of 4th edition

    True enough; my apologies for the mis-characterization! The 'firing' thread you referred to had a very personal tone overall, and I projected that onto your post. My bad. :\
  15. Silent Cartographer

    The Tielfling and The Gnome: On the Set of 4th edition

    It's not Meet the Engineer, but it is clever. The tiefling is annoying on purpose; they're intentionally playing on stereotypes. Insert tongue into cheek, etc. I have to wonder in awe at the serious emotional investment required for anyone to think this flash video is their personal D&D...
  16. Silent Cartographer

    Holiday Present - The Elf PHB entry

    Oh, and in regards to lifespan, I like the Shadowrun approach to elven lifespans. Best of both worlds... :cool:
  17. Silent Cartographer

    Holiday Present - The Elf PHB entry

    On balance, me likey mucho grande! Not perfect, but the flaws are small to meaningless, IMO. Heh. We get it that you hate. A lot. You could probably power several small desktop accessories off that much hate. In fact, I've just started a pot of tea off the residual intertubes hate-runoff from...
  18. Silent Cartographer

    D&D 4E 4e Races and Classes: "Why we changed the gods"

    BRILLIANT!!! ;) Bonus points for fitting her into the whole PoL setting thing, hehehe...
Top