Search results

Also: Have a much smaller stat block. One of the consequences of "no empty levels" design is that direct one-to-one PC class conversions fill up with a plethora of abilities that are cumbersome to write out and that most NPCs are unlikely to ever use. 1e/2e characters were much simpler...

Go ahead and tell that to the orderlies at the "mad mages" wing of the local sanitarium. I DARE you. I mean, when they get old and weak and mentally unstable, a fighter can STILL be disarmed. After which they're much less dangerous and do NOT burn everything flammable around them. Unless...

I don't really like the 2024 implementation. It just doesn't feel...evocative to me? I'm not sad to see the immunity against non-magic / silvered weapons go as that resulted in some tedious battles; though I think SOME sort of resistance to normal damage should have been kept for thematic...

And yet moving away from that model offended mass numbers of players, caused the greatest schism the hobby has ever known, and spawned what remains today the second most popular of all TTRPGs. Moving back towards that model is what returned market share to 5e. Circling back toward the...

Such... ephemeral beings, humans. Like cherry blossoms. Always crashing about heedlessly in a beautiful disaster.

Presumably, since neither Halflings nor Ogres normally or inherently possess that ability, that would be through skill and training. Any number of reasonably obvious ways. Do you REALLY need examples? Since the Brute ability does not actually specify how or why the extra damage occurs, we'll...

Because that would be unbalanced as a racial ability. However, martial advantage works just fine in a game world if considered to be a class ability. Narratively speaking, something like: Most hobgoblin societies delight in warfare; and force their young to train in weapon use from the moment...

Yeah, that explains SO much...

It creates a host of plot holes and narrative inconsistencies if and when, for example, a hobgoblin is able to blast something with a bazooka for 15 damage; but then pulls out a tiny, metal sewing needle yet is still to poke things for 15 damage. Without a very good in-game explanation...

Also from the 2024 MM: Higher CR pirate officers get a very significant base weapon damage multiplier on each attack...for no in-game rational, explicable reason. Which incidentally means that the pistol attacks of a CR 12 Pirate Admiral NPC deal exactly as much damage on average as the...

I would give them a Suggestion spell-like ability. (Maybe available at 5th level if you're making them into a PC race). And maybe add the following to their Shapeshifting ability: "Kitsune are unable to transform their tails when shapeshifting. And must hide their tails physically, such as...

To each their own. For whatever reason, Mending is one of the most commonly taken cantrips in the 5e games I've been running... so this would mean the penalties are unlikely to remain more than a single combat. Which makes the degradation effect too inconsequential IMHO.

I was initially hopeful about the 2024 ruleset. While the 2024 PHB featured notable power creep and significant nerfing or near complete removal of several classes of spells (such as summoning) I felt that the changes overall were beneficial. Summoning was, for example, often time consuming...

On the flip side of this, enemies that attack the party on sight are fairly infrequent in my games. One will occasionally meet stuff like hungry monsters hunting for a meal or supernatural foes like undead that have innate compulsions to kill; and maybe the odd ambush / mugging attempt - but...

In my present campaign, about half the party have set up a base in a small hamlet they previously saved. One of the PCs is a kobold, who has slowly been attracting and collecting other kobolds. The newly forming kobold colony keeps tunnelling through peoples' basements, stealing shiny objects...

I very strongly prefer that goblins and kobolds remain evil. Of course, I ALSO think that mindlessly pretend-slaughtering sentient creatures MERELY because one disagrees with their moral choices is something that should be discouraged.

Anyway, as to the OP: I've tried to DM sunless citadel a couple times. And also played through it a couple times. There are at least a couple decent fights - the wyrmling, for example. But...I don't know - it feels like there's a lot of... boringness at the beginning. Not exactly empty...

I've had a lot of tpks. Mostly homebrew stuff that I didn't properly vet against the players beforehand. Also mostly NOT 5e, but rather stuff like 3.5 or pathfinder. I did have one total party defeat once in 5e, but the enemies were trying to recover some stuff the party had taken, not kill...

I'm thinking this thread has MAYBE run its course. However, it's going to be a whole week before my next game session and I really love worldbuilding (which I'm sure is a great surprise to all), soo.. The Zyrficadian Empire is an expansionist, militaristic state that frequently attempts to...

There's some weirdness to it but yeah, Eberron is like that. Afaik canonically ONLY a member of House Cannith (the fabricators' guild) or someone with the Dragonmark of Making can build the lightning rail. But ONLY House Orien or someone with the Dragonmark of Passage is capable of driving...