Search results

Yeah, I think that might work as a quick fix, though maybe adding more spells to the good/evil lists might be better? More work though, probably. I leave that to the writers to determine as I don't really know what their intent was for the archetypes.

From my readings of PF2e, where rules are pretty exhaustively detailed, there are still plenty of ways to interpret (and misinterpret) the rules. I don't really think there is any foolproof, ironclad way to define any set of rules, unfortunately. That's not to say you shouldn't try, and I think...

I mean, that's not grammatically anything. But since it only grants you the expertise die until the beginning of your next turn, the only possible time an attack could happen is on the same turn. So no, you can't take an attack the next round to satisfy the requirements unless you're really...

What I am most excited about with LU is that I might actually be able to get people to play it. I've gotten kinda bored with O5e and the limitations it has in terms of what you can do with any given character and I would love to convert over to PF2e, but there are only a few of my friends that...

I mean, it says "Before you take the Attack action..." That pretty clearly indicates that you have to take the Attack action to use it.

That's the problem, though. Holy champions don't have those options. They have no options, actually. And having the option is really useful depending on the game. If you're in a game with a druid, the green knight really has nothing to offer in terms of spells that the druid can't do better (in...

But... If it's bad now, people won't keep supporting it so it won't have a future. And they will need to add 47 good, 48 evil, and 32 communication spells before that catch-up ever happens. Assuming maybe some overlap between those, that's still at least 100 spells. It's going to be years before...

You don't see it as a problem that you are granted access, as an unholy champion, to a spell school that doesn't net you a single spell while your nature-based friend gets 48? Future proofing is one thing, but you still need balance in the here and now. I want to play the game on release, not in...

It just seems rather off to me. I've been creating a holy champion and that gives me access to the good spell list. There are only 4 spells on that list; 2 of them are already Herald spells and 1 of them is too high of a level for me to ever cast, so I only actually get 1 additional spell...

I don't know about other people, but I could probably use some additional clarity on that point. The section on page 444 is describing the Use an Object action and saying if you are trying to drink a potion, which requires an action, you would use the Use an Object action, which is still an...

Sure, but remember that this isn't a video game and it's not like you're just going to sit in town for weeks farming gold. Narrator is going to get a little bored and drop a fireball on you or something to get you to leave.

Yeah, I know. I think that addresses that. You could take a dip into marshal and get the same benefit, though, so I really don't think it's a fighter-specific bug.

I doubt it's a bug, it's rather specifically called out in the section on multiclassing: "Heralds. The herald is an exception to this rule. If your first levels are in the herald class, you gain an exertion pool equal to twice your proficiency bonus." So I believe the idea is that regardless of...

Two smaller changes off the top of my head are that if you know a language, you also know how to sign it, and that gender has no place on the character sheet.

Oh! You work quickly. I guess I just assumed it was going to take longer for those tools to come out. I shall be patient, then.

I like that the class spell lists are with the classes, but there don't seem to be lists anywhere for all the other spell lists. Like I am creating a herald and he gets access to the good spell list, but as far as I can tell, there are only a handful of those and the only way to find out which...

Fair enough.

I know that's how it is in O5e, but in that case, there are a few classes that get additional increases (fighters, for example). In A5e, as far as I can tell everyone gets increases at the same rate, so they don't really seem to have any reason to be tied to your class levels. When it comes to...