Search results

  1. Victim

    What makes a controller a controller?

    By the same token, powers like Rain of Blood can offer more attack or damage bonuses than leader powers. Our Invoker had much better buffs than our laser type cleric (who had area stuff and healing). But you're right to a point; the PHB 1 WIS cleric options are very strongly controller...
  2. Victim

    What makes a controller a controller?

    People are right to consider the controller to be close cousin to the defender - both roles are focused on enemy action. To go through all the roles: A Striker is all about applying damage - both in large amounts, and where desired. Strikers have bonus damage with mobility/ranged (sometimes...
  3. Victim

    Tips to create and play an effective druid?

    Wow, you can Push or prone enemies and are good at charging! Wait, that's falls more into the barbarian's area of expertise than a controller's.
  4. Victim

    Essential Mage: The return of schools

    Spellstorm Mage is also pretty sweet too. The encounter power seems much better than the new blood pulse, especially since you can expand it normally with Resounding Thunder. Plus there's power recovery and a big selective daily, the AP feature is tasty (much better than bloodmage). It...
  5. Victim

    Essential Mage: The return of schools

    No. Most other controllers are worse than wizards. Invokers often have weaker conditions, smaller areas, and weaker zone dailies - they do have more party friendly powers and some good buffs, so they're the second best controller class. Druids are roughly at the warlock level of control...
  6. Victim

    Guild Wars 2 and the Future of Classes and Roles

    4e already changed healing. Nobody just heals, except the pacifist cleric. Instead it's a minor action, or extra benefit along with the attack power that you used. Even the laser cleric isn't just standing in the pack casting heals. And a lot of classes have little bits of support and...
  7. Victim

    July Errata is up

    Having a reliable default power doesn't really change the fact that if you can't swing a more effective power than your default, things are kind of bad. If things are actually challenging, then autohitting for weak damage isn't going to turn things around. It's just going to let you say "Look...
  8. Victim

    July Errata is up

    Yeah, our rogue has been built for mad mobility with Tumble, Ignoble Escape, Guerrilla Blitz and Speed 8. If anything, he's too fast; with his extra mobility he's sometimes tempted to go after more isolated monsters and work on them with all his CA granting stuff instead of focusing fire.
  9. Victim

    Oh wow. Countdown to Essentials

    Prismatic Burst seems really good for the wizard compared to 13 encounters from other controllers. In general, wizard encounters seem pretty good once you get past the level 3s.
  10. Victim

    Oh wow. Countdown to Essentials

    Only sort of. Essentially, the standard 4e convention enforces variety of everything except at wills. Even if you really like Rain of Blows, Storm of Blades, whatever, you can't use it all the time. The other powers are important too. If maybe you like one of your level 3 powers over some of...
  11. Victim

    Oh wow. Countdown to Essentials

    Considering that the power point system was one of the worst parts of PHB 3, I can't say that I'm enthused about further mechanics to change the mechanical structure of characters. I haven't seen too much praise online for the system where most characters will be using the same 'encounter...
  12. Victim

    D&D 4E How have PCs died in your 4e games?

    Yeah. But they're great fun to ride. :)
  13. Victim

    D&D 4E How have PCs died in your 4e games?

    In our current game: Invoker repeatedly blasted by area attacks and aura attacks dies. The leader is repeatedly dazed, stunned or dominated, so intervention couldn't come in time (one other character had a healing power, but forgot about it :( ). One PC caught alone was killed. Then, since...
  14. Victim

    Cloak of the Walking Wounded

    Non dwarves use Second Wind? The Cloak doesn't improve a group's surge efficiency at all, so they lose out on daily endurance compared to heals with bonuses to the surge value. Most of the time, I'd much rather have a Cloak with a different property or power. If your group needs to spend a...
  15. Victim

    How often do you use minions?

    They haven't been too common in our game, being used about once per adventure. Now that Solar Wrath is only Burst 3 instead of half the battlefield, maybe minions will see more action.
  16. Victim

    Has lack of an insider account kept you from playing 4E?

    Nope. It's not really that hard to remember the bits of errata most relevant to your own character. And if it is, you can just print out those sections of the updates.
  17. Victim

    General Monster Manual 3 Thread

    The Ghast has a story about some rogue sealing up from ghouls and then coming back years later. It seems like there are a ton of monsters that dominate and/or force people to make attacks against their allies. I guess that's one way to get around a monster damage problem - just have them use...
  18. Victim

    General Monster Manual 3 Thread

    The autumn nymph has an entry like that, as does some type of ghast IIRC. It's not especially common, but there are other entries like that.
  19. Victim

    General Monster Manual 3 Thread

    The sort of style mishmash makes it especially jarring. If you have some book where pretty much everything is described on an in world level with quotes and stories (the DL SAGA monster book), then it may be good or bad in execution, but it's a consistent concept. Or you could have the MM 1 or...
  20. Victim

    General Monster Manual 3 Thread

    Yeah, we figured - but we just got it today, and then had our group over, so we haven't taken the time to do that yet.
Top