Search results

So it's a video game now?

So it doesn't say you can't determine facing so I guess we can? Where is the rule stating you have simultaneousl line of sight in all directions?

So I had to go put my 4 hours in this month to keep the financial spreadsheet in the black. Coming back and reading the posts leaves me with a few observations/questions. 1- does the lack of a specific rule allowing something mean it is absent from the game? 2- does the lack of a specific...

Same here.

I understand the issue just as well as you do, we just don't agree on it. You're looking for a problem and found one, I'm looking for a solution and found one. Since we are not playing the game together we both are correct.

I never said it was, but it gets worse when rules or lack there of are not handled consistently.

It literally says "With the Hide action, you try to conceal yourself. To do so, you must succeed on a DC 15 Dexterity (Stealth) check while you’re Heavily Obscured or behind Three-Quarters Cover or Total Cover, and you must be out of any enemy’s line of sight;" In the definition of the hide...

" You win, everyone else must be wrong. Do i have to sign a release or a certificate that allow you to have won the conversation. Were just trying to explain the how and whys of things and you just keep asking for more. I think there is a term for that." I'm just trying to understand how...

If that is true, why wouldn't there be facing, there is no specific rule that says there isn't, though there's is a generalization rule that it is in the game.

So where is the specifc rule stating you have this omnivision?

Then why does it say "if you can see a creature, you can discern whether it can see you." If i can't know which direction you are facing, i.e. you can't see 360 degrees simultaneously.

I didn't ask you to write a rulebook, but to explain how you would build a non magical fire under water using the 24 5e rules.

So when it is not your turn do you have this omnivision then? Per the rules.

Sure but if my PC is hiding from your creature and I ask which direction you are facing so I can decide if you can see me then you would have to declare which way you are facing. You would still have a LOS, just not be looking down it, so not facing me.

It does not say you can see every LOS at the same time.

Magic fire may work underwater, but explain how you would build a non magical fire under water?

They are literally the same thing you can only see what is infront of your eyes, your eyes are on your face, thus LOS is in the direction you are facing.

How about a quote, a link, or a heading map to the entry, i don't have a physical copy.

Where is the rule that says a creature can see all the way around the simultaneously?

That doesn't mean it does not exist in the game, it is clearly far to situational for a rule to work. Where is the rule that says a creature can see all the way around the simultaneously?