Search results

  1. Crothian

    Pathfinder 1E Toying with Campaign Ideas.. have I stumbled on a good one here?

    It sounds fun. It has a pretty heavy plot going on with the invasion so as long as the players are fine with that then go for it.
  2. Crothian

    D&D 5E (2014) Advancing NPC's

    Are there any rules or talk in the PHB of gaining XP in any other way then through killing monsters?
  3. Crothian

    D&D 5E (2014) Minor rant - y'ever just hate your players' characters?

    I would love this. These two things don't go together and if that's what the party is then embrace it. Forming a Kingdom is hard under the best of circumstances but from social pariahs it is nearly impossible. I think that would be fun to run.
  4. Crothian

    Social Contract and you!

    When I run one shots at convention what I do is first introduce myself since most or all the people there won't know me. I ask the names of the players and then I ask who has had experience with the game before. Usually it is mix of experienced and people new to the system so I always ask the...
  5. Crothian

    D&D 5E (2014) How many of your campaigns ACTUALLY ever get to 20th level?

    In 1e I had a wizard go above 20th level but we were unsure of rules and I'm not sure how much of a campaign that was. These other were campaigns. I played an elven Wizard/thief to over 20th level as a thief but about 15th level as a Wizard. Most of the other characters were close to level 20...
  6. Crothian

    D&D 5E (2014) So.... about scrolls...

    I love that rule. My Barbarian is going to demand scrolls because he will unleash the power of the written word!
  7. Crothian

    D&D 5E (2014) What's one thing that pleasantly surprised you, and one thing that disappointed you about the PHB?

    Which is one more then I wanted to see. It means that the cap is no longer absolute once we see one exception it is easier for game designers to decide to bring in more.
  8. Crothian

    Horror Board Game Mechanics

    The RPG you are thinking of is Dread. A co op game like Pandemic does a good job of this as you can see the end coming and you know if certain cards get drawn an outbreak happens and it can spread and do all kinds of damage. The hidden traitor games like Battlestar Galactica and Shadows over...
  9. Crothian

    D&D 5E (2014) What's one thing that pleasantly surprised you, and one thing that disappointed you about the PHB?

    I don't have the PHB but it does seem that the 20 attribute limit is not as much of a rule as I was hoping it was. That disappoints me. I am pleased with the amount of fun sounding options.
  10. Crothian

    How could the Tarrasque still possibly be alive?

    How the Mighty Are Fallen is a FR adventure that does have the creature in it.
  11. Crothian

    D&D 5E (2014) Sneak Attack with spells?

    Basic just says level without clarification that I can see.
  12. Crothian

    D&D 5E (2014) Splatbooks in 5E, way or no way?

    Splat books are pretty much the business model for a successful RPG product line these days. There are plenty of options in the PHB but there are also a number of character concepts I've seen in the past few years that cannot be created yet.
  13. Crothian

    D&D 5E (2014) 5th Edition -- Help Me Break the Game!

    That might be the first character concept that would be required to use a computer and dice roller at the table. I might also have that game use minis and force the players to provide minis for their own character and any creatures they will be using. :D
  14. Crothian

    D&D 5E (2014) The Worst Capstone Abilities

    Does that allow the barbarian to go above the 20 attribute limit?
  15. Crothian

    D&D 5E (2014) 5th Edition -- Help Me Break the Game!

    Those were problems because DMs did not enforce the rules. DMs handing out the wrong kind of magical items is a DM issue not a rules issue. But the most important thing to remember about 1e and earlier is it was never said to be a balanced system. They made stuff up that sounded fun I'm not...
  16. Crothian

    D&D 5E (2014) 5th Edition -- Help Me Break the Game!

    In the "game days of old" this kind of thing really didn't happen. Sure Unearthed Arcana in 85 added some power to the classes but it was nothing the DM could not handle.
  17. Crothian

    D&D 5E (2014) Ranger

    Thank goodness combat is just one part of the game. Can anyone judge the class on the game as a whole and not just a specific aspect of it?
  18. Crothian

    This Weekend @ The BoxOffice: 2014_Aug.03

    I just don't see how a tornado without sharks in it is scary :confused:
  19. Crothian

    D&D 5E (2014) The Burden of Being Small

    Unless the book specifically says "All small creatures are this mechanically verse all medium creatures are this" then we really can't say. It looks like that there is no universal truth about small creatures we just have a limited selection on small and medium creatures. All that can be done is...
  20. Crothian

    D&D 5E (2014) 5th Edition -- Help Me Break the Game!

    Breaking the game is more about the DM then the game. Some DMs no matter what rules exploits you use will be able to handle it with no problem. Other DMs crack even when the players are playing very average characters.
Top