Search results

Well, I think we have reached a good spot, I feel good about this... I feel the silence is a pretty telling sign that really, my points are valid. I'm not trying to tell you guys how to run this thing... it's just my gut tells me this is the wrong way to do this. And I always go with my gut...

I can understand you trying to defend the decision that was made here, but that first sentence was made because no one had yet explained to me the reasons behind it. Now, I don't think it's arbitrary anymore, but I still think it is a wasted venture... which leads me to your second statement...

Okay, let me start by stating that like I mentioned earlier, I totally appreciate all the work the Adventurer's League and it's volunteers do. I mean the amount of time and dedication that you folks give is huge and you truly deserve recognition for it. When I said hasty I did not mean that...

Well, I guess that settles it... We are obviously exactly where we want to be... I'm just so glad all those volunteers will have such an easier time now, instead of all of those rigorous complex hours that they would have had... I mean gosh, just saying all official WoTC books are Legal just...

Again, I'm not upset about the ruling, it actually doesn't affect any my current character builds at all. And I can appreciate the ruling given in the haste and pressure that was given to Adventurer's League. However, the grounds of that this book was not play tested with this other book as...

Yeah, but how many splat books went with that, according to WoTC this will not be the case this edition. Anyways, I realize that nothing will change with this discussion, just voicing my opinion... and in that everyone is entitled to it. Also, let's also not fault LFR with just that as its...

With much sincere respect kalana, I can appreciate your position. And to be honest even the Adventurer's Leagues as well. However, realistically, citing play testing as the source of this ruling only furthers my point. Power gaming will happen no matter the deterrent you place. Maybe...

And let's look at how the responses have come to this point... nothing. There are zero arguments that hold any light as to a real good reason as to why there is this ruling. ...other than our "top" men looked into this and made such and such call. I'm not really that upset with the ruling...

Okay, I'll bite... If I were a professional burglar, trust me, neither of those locks would be an issue. And likely, I'd plan it at a time that your neighbors were either not home or were engaged in some other thing... So, yeah, we can go back and forth at this all day, but that just seems...

Lol, fair point, but still the fact remains, if I wanted to break into your house, locks or not, I'm getting in. I'm just saying making arbitrary rules for arbitrary reasons doesn't lend itself to an inclusive experience. People who want to power game will, and to be honest the more you...

I'm cool with the ruling, but in general, the ruling of this material is valid for this session vs that session, seems a bit more complicated than it is worth. I mean, most of the options present in the SCAG are fluff based at best to get players more into role-playing. These rules feel more...

That's fine, he is a regular player at my store, that should be fine.

Ahhhh... I see, well then, we must all band together to preserve these spells... luckily I have a fellow wizard in my party who is playing a Deep Gnome and does not want to respec into the SCAG material... so EEPC spells for me for life! lol

So, if I chose SCAG as my starting resource, I can't add spells from EEPC unless I "find" them during a module, via a spell book or scroll? What about when I level, can one of the two spells that I learn as I level come from EEPC? Can I purchase them in a EE module if there is a store that...

Similar question with Background choices, if I chose a Background from SCAG, does that lock me out of the spells from EE? And if so, what if I find them during an adventure? Can I purchase them later?

So, I'm sure my answer lies somewhere within this 22 Page post, but I'm lazy... So, the question is... Are the spells that are offered in either supplement book allowed no matter which book you chose for your origin? Meaning, I play a character with the SCAG cantrip option of Booming Blade...

[/sblock] This is sooooo awesome, it feels great that you guys could see the value as I did! You are an great team, thanks again for making this happen, I know I have a particular player who be ecstatic to possible get this item.

Yay! This is fantastic news, thank you so much for the heads up! I'll continue to wait patiently to hear the final verdict of where this will be placed...

You... you might be right, better to be safe, we don't want to get sued... I mean Blizzard isn't Apple, but it could happen...

*Smiling calmly while he sits patiently waiting for an answer like a young child awaiting to open Christmas presents on Christmas morning... All the while twirling his thumbs and his eyes not even blinking. Then in a soft whisper he says* Shortly...