Search results

  1. MerakSpielman

    Daze vs. swimming creature

    So I have two contradictory opinions.... When it happened, I ruled that the creature sank, then I rolled some swim checks after the spell wore off to see if it could get to the surface... it couldn't, not with all that armor on.
  2. MerakSpielman

    Where to find XPs for item creation?

    Part of the whole mechanic of item creation is that by getting magical items your character gets more powerful, so this is compensated for by slowing XP progression. Are you trying to find a way around this limitation?
  3. MerakSpielman

    Hexes or Squares?

    Hexes are nice because they allow for more precise movement, eliminating the weirdness of the "diagonal move" in a grid. Hexes suck because it's difficult to draw square rooms or buildings. There's constant questions (is this partial hex big enough for my character to stand on, etc). There's...
  4. MerakSpielman

    Monster classes

    I mentioned once that I had no problems slapping class levels on monsters, intelligent or not, just to make them an interesting challange for the party. You know, black puddings with levels of Monk, stirges with levels of rogue, things like that. I do this knowing that the creatures can't have...
  5. MerakSpielman

    What's a "unique being" for purposes of Gate?

    If that mythos (which I'm not convinced is intended to be in D&D at all) is really that important to you, I suggest each extraplanar creature have a secret True Name which cannot be magically divined, but would allow a caster to Gate in individuals without giving them a choice.
  6. MerakSpielman

    requiring players to buy books

    I require my players either have a copy of the PHB or access to the SRD outside of the game so they can properly update their character sheets. During the game, I heartily recommend them owning their own copy so they can look up rules and spells during the game.
  7. MerakSpielman

    What's a "unique being" for purposes of Gate?

    See, I might be convinced to allow the players to summon a "fiendish, vampiric ancient blue dragon" and it wouldn't get a choice. In an infinite multiverse there are, after all, an infinite number of such beasts somewhere. But if the party wanted to Gate in "Sharzzakhar, consort to the Great...
  8. MerakSpielman

    Magic weapons with no "bonus"

    I might allow a "no bonus" magic weapon, but it wouldn't count as a magical weapon for purposes of bypassing damage reduction.
  9. MerakSpielman

    can a deaf person blindfight?

    Nothing mystical involved... I'd assume blind fight meant the character is good at anticipating a creature's movements based on scant information. I'd allow this, and assume that knowing where it last attacked you from or being able to figure out what part of its body your last blow connected...
  10. MerakSpielman

    Daze vs. swimming creature

    This happened a while ago IMC but I just remembered it and wondered what you thought. What happens if you cast Daze on somebody who is swimming? What happens if they're wearing chain mail and have, up to this point, been barely making their swim checks? Do they just sink?
  11. MerakSpielman

    Iron Bands of Bilarro and Coup de Grace?

    If the target is capable in any way of responding to your attack, even such a simple motion as turning their head or rolling would be enough to not be "helpless" per the rules. Helpless is a very specific condition and very few situations grant it.
  12. MerakSpielman

    Newthread.php error

    I have been unable to post a new thread since the upgrade. I've only tried 3 times for 3 different threads, but still....
  13. MerakSpielman

    Spellcraft ?

    I don't think it matters if the spell is on your list or not.
  14. MerakSpielman

    What's a "unique being" for purposes of Gate?

    Cure and Inflict spells do not have the [Good] or [Evil] descriptors.
  15. MerakSpielman

    How does reincarnate affect mental stats?

    I would remove racial bonuses/penalties for mental stats and apply the ones from the new race. This could result in situations where the PC has some stats lowered and none raised. Sucks to be you. At least you're not dead.
  16. MerakSpielman

    Requirements for creating flesh golems

    Question: Limited Wish costs 300xp. Does this cost have to be incurred every day of the crafting process?
  17. MerakSpielman

    Newthread.php error

    Just got a blank page trying to post a new thread in Rules. Titled "Swimming and Daze" or something, if that helps.
  18. MerakSpielman

    What's a "unique being" for purposes of Gate?

    You know, it would be amusing to let Gate summon an outsider of any HD. Except there's a catch. You both roll an opposing check (where the bonus is caster level of the wizard and HD of the critter). If you make the check, the creature is bound to your service per the normal spell description. If...
  19. MerakSpielman

    What's a "unique being" for purposes of Gate?

    If you are capable of calling an outsider by name than I think it should qualify as a unique being. Off-hand, I'd say that only the being named by the caster of the Gate could come through. Of course, the being could disguise itself as an underling and come through, claiming its master sent it...
  20. MerakSpielman

    Is 3rd edition too "quantitative"

    The game is as qualitative as you make it. Sure it's not in the default rules, but who cares? You're playing it, you can do whatever you want to add flavor.
Top