Search results

  1. Storminator

    What's a good way to include many secondary combatants in a fight?

    What if the minions had a damage aura instead of attacks? Move next to you, activate aura, 5 damage. Then minions from each side would kill each other in waves, and each would do some small amount of damage to PCs (who are 12th level and shouldn't worry too much about minions) or the serious...
  2. Storminator

    What's a good way to include many secondary combatants in a fight?

    In my next session, the party will be starting a fight. In addition to the party vs. main opposition fight, there will many lesser combatants on both sides. What's a good way to include those combatants without bogging the game down brutally? Obviously they should be minions, but what other...
  3. Storminator

    Is 'Good vs Evil' fantasy better for long-term campaigns than more 'amoral' Swords & Sorcery?

    I'll echo others that say you need a strong hook and GvE provides that pretty cheap. My current campaign has "you're all goblinoids" as it's hook, and it's holding the group together very well, even 3 years on. Is there any reason you couldn't make more likeable NPCs in your sword and sorcery...
  4. Storminator

    D&D 4E Yet another thread on Mortality and Death in 4E

    Our games have seen a bunch of deaths as well - many single PCs, a couple pairs, one trio, one quad, and one TPK. But none of that compares to the 1e days. We would send 8 PCs into a 1st level adventure and half of them would die. Then we'd send another 8 into another 1st level adventure, half...
  5. Storminator

    Pathfinder 1E How would you defend an airship?

    Get some way to quickly cross the distance to the enemy ship - far faster than flying there. Your best defense against enemy airships is to send PCs onto their decks. Perhaps develop a method of quickly freeing the enemy ship's bound elemental. Then you can both knock them out of the sky and...
  6. Storminator

    D&D 5E (2014) Barbarian vs Fighter vs Monk

    I'm not suggesting you run another set of scenarios, but fighting one powerful monster should be in the barbarian's wheelhouse. Taking half damage from large hits is going to help more against one big attack per round. If they fought 3 lower level monsters the fighter might look tougher, as he...
  7. Storminator

    2 Ways To Abandon Roles

    That's a Warlord power, right? ;) PS
  8. Storminator

    The Goblins of Eberron try to start a war . . .

    Had another session of my Goblins of Eberron game yesterday. This is the 2nd consecutive session of trying to start a war. A certain bugbear tribe will ally with our "heroes" if they can get the Llesh Haruuc to declare war on the elves of Valenar, but the Llesh won't do it unless other nations...
  9. Storminator

    Fan sites to keep the edition alive?

    4e is my favorite edition of D&D, and likely to be my game of choice for . . . ever? . . . but I don't think it'll ever generate the most discussion. It's not as interesting to talk about IMX, nor is it as necessary. 3.x requires some pretty deep system mastery, and has pretty arcane rules...
  10. Storminator

    Top Ten D&D Settings of ALL TIME!

    While I have preferences, and wouldn't have ordered them like that, I'd play in any of those settings. PS
  11. Storminator

    Miniatures and Role-playing games

    Even when we played 1e we used minis constantly. For D&D, where movement rates are low, they are a great tool for precise tactical combats. They are fantastic for 4e, which really rewards a tactical focus. And the game where you can break out whole armies is awesome. I've never used minis for...
  12. Storminator

    D&D 4E Questions for my very first 4E Character/Adventure.

    You see how S'mon used his Twin Post power there? Well played sir . . . PS
  13. Storminator

    4 Elements at the Core of 4e

    Right - everyone's good at combat so it holds true there. But that doesn't apply to skill challenges, where players can frequently try their crazy idea, even with a -1 CHA mod and no training in Bluff. PS
  14. Storminator

    4 Elements at the Core of 4e

    The "Roll 9+" really only applies to things you're good at. Trying an untrained skill with your dump stat means you might need to roll an 18. I've seen encounters were I, as the DM, was able to force the players to work without their strengths - FREX continuously hitting the strikers, while only...
  15. Storminator

    Who's your favorite character?

    That's pretty much it. More fun, less work. Kinda like a hobby . . . He did have the bonus schtick of being a "stereotypical dwarf", in that he never met another dwarf outside his family, so everything he knew about dwarf culture came from watching human plays that included dwarves. Hilarity ...
  16. Storminator

    How did Trek Become Such a Phenomenon?

    ToS had a very consistent inconsistency. Every week the Federation was assumed to have solved all of human foibles except the one on display this week. It always isolated one failing and worked its morality play around it. Then next week, that one was solved again and a new failing cropped up. PS
  17. Storminator

    What happens to this forum at the end of the week?

    Are the threads moved to make way for a new spotlight? Locked? Left to clutter things up? PS
  18. Storminator

    Who's your favorite character?

    My first real 4e PC was a lot of fun. Thraak, dwarven cleric. He embodied a lot of departures from my old gaming mentality. I used to take lots of notes, have a detailed inventory, and spend a lot of time thinking about my characters away from the game. That all got too exhausting. Thraak's...
  19. Storminator

    Pathfinder 1E Sending Animal Companion to "Retrieve" Companion

    Absolutely. It would also take one of the character's actions to give the order (I no longer remember what type of action it takes in 3.x), but I would just have the animal companion do it. PS
  20. Storminator

    Pathfinder 1E Sending Animal Companion to "Retrieve" Companion

    I would have said "ok, your leopard does that" and moved on. PS
Top