Search results

  1. Odysseus

    Am I breaking any rules with this tactic?

    The plan can work, just your interpretation of how it works within the rules doesn't. IMO it would be Step 1.Haz checks door for traps etc Step 2.Haz opens door. Surprise round. Party use surprise round to move. Step 3. Intitive.If kobolds get better inititve, plan goes sour. But no plan...
  2. Odysseus

    What do you NEED in a starting town?

    You need to be able to answer certain questions . Questions like. Whats happening in the town with or without the partys interaction? If someone breaks the law in town, how do the deal with it? And what are the town laws? If you want to buy or sell stuff where do you go? If the party wanted a...
  3. Odysseus

    How do you feel about raising longbow damage?

    I've used d12 for heavy crossbows, and that worked fine. However you might want to consider making mighty bows more available. A plus to damage if the welder has the strength seems more realistic than increasing damage dice for bows.
  4. Odysseus

    Weapon Speed - changing the way BAB works

    That agument is, armour is encumberence, encumberence effects max dexterirty, and max dexterity should effect the max number of attacks . Which does sort of sound right, but its effect on game play would be terrible. Thats right. Reach , intitive and movement rules are already in the rulebook...
  5. Odysseus

    Weapon Speed - changing the way BAB works

    The way I'd use this would be to have the bonus/penalty apply on the 2nd and subsquent attacks by the same weapon in the same round. So example a very fast weapon +2, with a BAB of +14/+9/+4 , you get +2 on the +9, and +4 attacks if using the same weapon.
  6. Odysseus

    long long post about my system of choice problem...

    What I think is the strength of 3rd edition is the D20 system. The basic format is great. You can switch from D&D to star war, and still understand the rules. My advice is stick with D20 but cut down the options and supplements. Plus with character creation, make the skill rank distribution set...
  7. Odysseus

    5ft. step triggered by Speak?

    I think I understand your point now. Although the SRD says "a 5' step does not count as a action", it is still an act. Because its an act,even if a small one, you can only use it on your inititive. I don't belive it specificly says this anywhere. However if you allowed this then really any...
  8. Odysseus

    5ft. step triggered by Speak?

    If you had a readied action to react to speech. Then the speech could trigger an action, which could be a 5' step. However the phb p144, says dms may not allow character speech outside their turn to warn other characters(so that they can react.) And a 5' step , although not a action, still only...
  9. Odysseus

    In Character Embezzlin` - Another Taboo?

    If a character is doing it, as long as its out in the open, where the other players know about it. It isn't a taboo. Although you've got to ask about what will happen when the rest of the characters find out. The only negative impact IME was when a character was taking his pick from the loot...
  10. Odysseus

    Albany ,NY. Looking for a D&D group

    I've just moved into the area and i'm looking for a D&D group to join, or start. I can DM or play as necessary. And anywhere in the Albany, Hudson, Chatham area would be great.
  11. Odysseus

    Reactive movement

    Hit the deck , is great. The other two I think would be better as feats, or be a little more specific about when they can be used. Other reactive movement options you could use might be improvised cover, you pick up a near-by stool and use it for cover. Or jump on table, rather than take a 5' step.
  12. Odysseus

    Two extra skill points per level (and character backgrounds)

    What i've tried is, to give out skill ranks as bonuses, like experience points. No more than 2 per level. Usually in knowledge skills, but it varies depending on what the character has been doing.
  13. Odysseus

    Booting players - What are your nightmare stories?

    I've kicked a few players out over the years. Usually players with attendance problems are reasonable , and if you ask them for a minimum attendace level, they'll agree or leave. My one nightmare story was a guy , who was a serious power gamer and rules lawyer. Which wasn't a problem by itself...
  14. Odysseus

    Do you still feel the wonder you had in your childhood games?

    The event I most remember about my early D&D games was meeting a troll, and not knowing anything about regeneration . We spent hours trying to figure out how to kill the troll. I still have enjoyable moments like that playing D&D , not the same , but just as enjoyable. So yes I still feel the...
  15. Odysseus

    1000 Signs you're in GM HELL

    246. A player declares his hobbit character is so big, he can use medium sized weapons ,singles handed without penalty. 247. You tell the group to have anything they want for character creation, just keep it low powered. And a player comes back with a character with all 18+ stats. 248. One of...
  16. Odysseus

    Can the rules do this?...

    The effect is the same as bullrush, so i'd use the same rules. Iron might has rules for this, Forced movement, attack at -10 if succesful oppent is move 5', but not into a occupied sqaure.
  17. Odysseus

    <Rant> Where has courtesy gone?

    How often do you see people in a hurry, but with no where go! I think the entropy of the polite society doesn't lie with a new generation, but with everybody. Everybody is too much of a hurry to give other people a thought, let alone a polite word. As to stopping to help people. When I moved to...
  18. Odysseus

    Apply Armour Check Penalty to REF save... why not?

    I think to make the idea work. Armour would have to reduce damage. Which it does in systems like the conan rpg. However with D&D I don't thinks its a practical idea.
  19. Odysseus

    Puzzle/Riddle based modules?

    The desert of desolation series. Pharaoh, and the tomb of martek both have some good puzzles. But arn't just about puzzles and traps.
  20. Odysseus

    Tell me about your favorite character of all time.

    It would have to be Ogrebane. He started as a basic edition Fighter. He wasn't so much my favourite, but he gained such a reputation among players , even people I didn't know. They'd heard of the character before they'd met me.
Top