Search results

  1. Gardens & Goblins

    D&D 5E (2014) Relative popularity of the Xanathar's Subclasses

    One of these things is not like the others..
  2. Gardens & Goblins

    D&D 5E (2014) What can an elf do during a trance?

    Dance. Dance like nobody is watching.
  3. Gardens & Goblins

    D&D 5E (2014) Oriental Adventures 5e: How would you do it?

    If the 'Oriental' in the title refers to a person or people, I'd agree that it could be taken as offensive. And we can and do refer to items, objects, history, language, literature and other cultural elements as oriental, both within and outside of academia. Oriental Adventures can be read...
  4. Gardens & Goblins

    D&D 5E (2014) Oriental Adventures 5e: How would you do it?

    I wonder if the debate around the word 'oriental' is an 'American thing'? I know it is a no-no according to federal law now. My co-worker's PHD is in the area of Oriental Studies - I've always wondered how that figures in to the debate. I'm originally from the UK but have lived in Japan and...
  5. Gardens & Goblins

    D&D 5E (2014) 2 PC Wizards Copying Each others spell books

    I welcome all scholars of the arcane and thank them for letting me copy their research. And they can get stuffed if they thinking I'm letting them copy my research. The power to incinerate crowds, bend minds and open gates to hell is the kind of power I trust only my self to have. I can...
  6. Gardens & Goblins

    Plane Shift: Ixalan is More Magic: the Gathering For Your D&D!

    Would have preferred some classes - always nice to see what they come up with. For me, not as good as the others, but very pretty. And a lot of + Charisma races it seems.
  7. Gardens & Goblins

    D&D 5E (2014) Familiars! What's your Homebrew ?

    1) To be clear - are you aware that the spell Find Familiar summons: Normally a caster can re-cast Find Familiar to change their familiar spirit's form. Is this still the case with these feats? If so, Find Familiar stands to become a 1st level spell/low cost resource that can potentially grant...
  8. Gardens & Goblins

    D&D 5E (2014) Survivor XGTE New Feats- WOOD ELF MAGIC WINS!

    DOWNVOTES ARE BACK TO TWO. PLEASE COPY AND PASTE THIS. Dragon Fear 17 Dwarven Fortitude 11 Fey Teleportation 22 Prodigy 10 Wood Elf Magic 17
  9. Gardens & Goblins

    D&D 5E (2014) "My Character Is Always..." and related topics.

    This is what I wanted to address with regards to mechanical or DM arbitration, in the context of 'smart play' attempting to circumvent challenges/gain auto successes. Specifically, I'm all for supporting a player's character concept and if they suddenly ignore or go against their own...
  10. Gardens & Goblins

    D&D 5E (2014) "My Character Is Always..." and related topics.

    Ok :) All good - different strokes and all that.
  11. Gardens & Goblins

    D&D 5E (2014) "My Character Is Always..." and related topics.

    I believe my examples make it clear that its not happening arbitrarily - and every effort is made to be fair. However, some folks will insist on making decisions based on player-perceived advantage, regardless if it is appropriate for their character, such as the classic low-charisma, no socials...
  12. Gardens & Goblins

    D&D 5E (2014) How to model a party of cinematically charismatic heroes?

    To build on this, there are many (movie) characters that are/can be quite horrible within their (movie) universe - but are still loved by the audience. For example, Gollum from the LOTR movies or K-2SO from Rogue One. Its arguable that for us as an audience to like or even love characters, they...
  13. Gardens & Goblins

    D&D 5E (2014) "My Character Is Always..." and related topics.

    To repeat/clarify - a 'Wisdom check.. ..as needed. Ideally though...'. In other words, within the context of what I typed - we shouldn't need to resort to checks to support (enforce? Eugh..) roleplaying. However, they are an option, a tool on the tool belt. I would prefer our table not needing...
  14. Gardens & Goblins

    D&D 5E (2014) Quarterstaff, shield and polearm master

    Isn't this because the designers wanted to lump a sturdy, metal-shod/bound 'Western-stye' quarterstaff and an 'Eastern-style' Bo staff under the same stat block? Saying this, I can totally get behind a club also sharing the stat block with a Hanbō, being a 1d4 Light weapon - and obviously much...
  15. Gardens & Goblins

    D&D 5E (2014) Theme for my bard

    Ah ha! A classic case presenting as 'Character Performance Anxiety'. Friend, as @Hawk Diesel suggests, go with whatever sounds the most fun. Forget the numbers, comparing your character to others and trying to be the best. Simply make something as stylistically awesome as possible and try your...
  16. Gardens & Goblins

    D&D 5E (2014) "My Character Is Always..." and related topics.

    You've answered the question! :) A player could make the effort to develop a long checklist of sensible things their character does before going drinking/delving/dancing etc. Now, ideally they'd do this because such a strategy is something their character would do - such behaviour might suggest...
  17. Gardens & Goblins

    D&D 5E (2014) "My Character Is Always..." and related topics.

    While we assume characters complete tasks they're well skilled in without rolls/checks, with regards to how they operate within an environment/respond to an encounter, each player needs to make the DM aware of any action/strategy their character has adopted. For example, tracing their hands...
  18. Gardens & Goblins

    D&D 5E (2014) Desperately need help, trying to catch up to party.

    To clarify, I'm assuming it's designed around the standard array - or at least a base line in that ball park because.. well, practicalities. And also, just for the gurners at the back of the bus, rolling for stats is totally aok. Having characters with big stat lines is also totally aok...
Top