Search results

Yup. I feel this set-up is distressing common, and the social contract combined with the official rules puts pressure on the GM to knuckle under and give up on their preferences in this matter, which leads to an unhappy GM and, ultimately IMO, a poor game.

I'd love to see 3pp tackling this issue!

Unfortunately for some folks here, I feel this has to remain a table issue unless WotC can be convinced that there's money in promoting a different paradigm of rest & recovery.

Of course, it's always possible that the players are having fun with the nova loop and 5mwd, but the GM wants something else. That's certainly where I'd fall, and it's a real problem.

I think the anecdotes of folks here have shown that your perspective on time pressure and its effects on players is not an unassailable position. Some people won't care, and others will take said pressure as the mark of an adversarial GM and push back outside of play.

It is possible to disagree with someone's opinion and choices, even strenuously, while still respecting their right to make those choices. Otherwise folks can't really discuss different perspectives.

Isn't 3) just 2) (narrative rhythm) in a different context?

PCs are welcome to assume time pressure in every scenario, but if it isn't apparent I'm not going to bring it up without cause.

There can be time pressure, it just isn't always or nearly always a thing in every adventuring activity IMO. Even when it is there, it isn't always or nearly always so strong that taking a day off to rest is ridiculous. That's part of the setting too.

Excellent point. I use similarly broad tables in my Level Up game.

I suspect it's because players really like it, but maybe that's just me.

The tomb full of undead. Far less likely to generate time pressure on its own than your count's mansion scenario

The rules about resting aren't exactly "murky" IMO, but you have every right make your own houserules at your table, so long as the players are on board (and it sounds like they are).

I don't use Leomund's Bunker in my 5e, but yeah, pretty much.

That is IMO a decent way to generate pressure, especially when the in-setting circumstances don't do that job already. But even that isn't plausible in every circumstance.

I agree time pressure can be a factor often, but since it doesn't have to be, and there are plenty of plausible scenarios where it isn't, I don't believe that assuming it is a logical choice to make.

No, they're just arguing that taking action that exploits that knowledge as a PC inevitably makes you a jerk, to my reading.

Plausibility of specific unknowns is a factor. My scenario is less likely to result in negatives from taking a rest than yours, but both can happen in D&D.

I think the situations where mindless monsters are the threat are a bit too common to say the opposite is true "almost all the time".

It sounds to me like you're saying real world example shouldn't carry any weight at all in this discussion. Am I reading you correctly? Obviously I disagree, but that's a fair opinion.