Search results

  1. Clint_L

    The Many Faces of Roleplaying: How ‘RPG’ Became Everything and Nothing

    Of course it's imprecise. That's a feature, not a flaw: it's a broad term within which various sub-categories, and sub-sub-categories, etc. are subsumed. That's just...how language works. We understand, for example, that the word "sports" denotes certain very general features, while "baseball"...
  2. Clint_L

    D&D General Settings of Hope vs Settings of Despair

    I run my campaign worlds like I see the real world: people are complicated, so are their social systems, and sometimes they do bad things. If history has shown us anything, it's that people can do terrible things even with supposedly good intentions. Often because of supposedly good intentions...
  3. Clint_L

    D&D General What's your view on a pirate-driven campaign?

    Drinking rum. Edit: my campaign kicked off one game where the party had to rescue the captain's rum from some harpies.
  4. Clint_L

    Spoilers Fantastic Four (Spoilers)

    Agreed - superheroes are typically extreme deontologists, concerned with the moral principle, not loosey-goosey consequentialists who focus on the greater good. Refusing to sacrifice any baby, not just their own, is extremely on brand for the FF.
  5. Clint_L

    D&D General I asked AI: "What's the Most Common Cause of Character Death?"

    You mean they're checking their DMs when they shoud be paying attention to the game, so I kill their character with a lightning bolt?
  6. Clint_L

    Your top 5 sci-fi movies (and why)

    I saw it at a drive-in in Langley.
  7. Clint_L

    D&D General I asked AI: "What's the Most Common Cause of Character Death?"

    I find those AI responses interesting, because LLMs are essentially aggregators of the most typical responses, which makes them kind of useless for generating anything original, but potentially useful if you want a kind of "wisdom of crowds" response...which is arguably particularly relevant for...
  8. Clint_L

    D&D General Tales from Woodcreek Session 0

    Just watching this over on the Dungeon Dudes, and it is just delightful! I really enjoy Deborah Ann Woll's DM style - she keeps things fun and fast-paced, and Ginny Di and Anjali Bhimani are similarly joyful players, so the tone is light. Although it's called Session 0, it's really more of a...
  9. Clint_L

    D&D General What's your view on a pirate-driven campaign?

    I just wrapped a 4 month long pirate arc in my home campaign, and here's how I handled it: 1. The PCs were crew but it was obvious pretty quickly that they had special skills, so the captain basically used them as a kind of strike team, which dovetailed nicely with the PC's own motivations for...
  10. Clint_L

    D&D 5E (2024) 2nd level casters are disappoint

    It pretty typical for the even numbered levels to feel less impactful for full casters, though level 2 does offer more than a single spell slot. For example, if you're a wizard you also learn a new spell and get to choose expertise in a skill. Given that level 2 is only a few levels, I don't...
  11. Clint_L

    D&D 5E (2014) Not upgrading? What version of D&D 5e are you sticking with?

    Mastery alone makes them more powerful than their 2014 incarnations. Mastery is a LOT stronger than a lot of folks realize, when you math out the various effects. Martial classes in general got the most buffs; paladins remain a top tier class. Maybe not THE top class, as many felt previously...
  12. Clint_L

    D&D 5E (2014) Not upgrading? What version of D&D 5e are you sticking with?

    Well, every 2024 class is OP against 2014 classes. Maybe not moon Druids. But everyone else. However, monk from being a consensus bottom tier class to a consensus top tier class. For those arguing 2014 monk is fine, most players did not agree, and evidently, neither did WotC, since they...
  13. Clint_L

    D&D General Should you Multiclass?

    I don't enforce that rule - if players wanna multiclass, they can.
  14. Clint_L

    Who's on your geek Mount Rushmore?

    Yeah, but now I have to reassess my choices. Again. How could I have left off Stan Lee?
  15. Clint_L

    Who's on your geek Mount Rushmore?

    Dammit.
  16. Clint_L

    Who's on your geek Mount Rushmore?

    ...are awesome, but geek culture? They're too cool. Like, above, someone cited Bowie. He would be top of my list of personal icons, cultural icons, and music icons, Mt. Rushmore for all three, but geek Rushmore?
  17. Clint_L

    Who's on your geek Mount Rushmore?

    Hmmm...nerds, only, huh? Tolkien Gibson Lucas Shelley Edit: I really want to put Miyamoto on there but can't decide who to bump! Might have to be Gibson, but...I can't! Edit 2: How can Gygax not be up there? This is too hard! Edit 3: Okay, restricted myself to one per media: Tolkien Gygax...
  18. Clint_L

    D&D General Should you Multiclass?

    I do think it's a testament to 5e's design balance that multi-classing works as well as it does - mixing and matching with other classes could be fraught with balance issues, but it's not, particularly.
  19. Clint_L

    D&D General Should you Multiclass?

    Most of my players do not multiclass, but the ones who do generally do it for conceptual reasons that are tied to their character's story. As a DM, I don't find multiclassing a problem, but none of my players are remotely power gamers, so it's not an issue in that regard. One advantage of...
  20. Clint_L

    Dungeons & Dragons Releases Updated Unearthed Arcana for Arcane Subclasses

    Monk Way of the Tattooed Warrior has cool flavour but is very underwhelming compared to the current subclass options. Disappointing.
Top