Search results

  1. S

    The OGL -- Just What's Going On?

    I tend to run OSR stuff with 5e, which works a lot better than WotC 5e published adventures. I'm not sure how WotC manage to be so bad at it but I've not really seen a good adventure from them since Forge of Fury. Some of the mini adventures in the Essentials Kit are ok. For 5e rules adventures...
  2. S

    The OGL -- Just What's Going On?

    Good post. I'm two sessions in to a 5e Basic campaign using the 2014 Basic rules (print copy from Lulu) as primary resource, set in the Grand Duchy of Karameikos, Threshold from the 1983 red and blue boxes. Excellent ruleset! It avoids all the broken bits of 5e, clearly these were the spells and...
  3. S

    How’s the Marmoreal Tomb?

    I'm a big megadungeon fan these days. Arden Vul is amazing and ridiculously big. Stonehell is minimalist presentation but very good. And the minimalism means it's cheap. I do suggest adding more connections to level 6 from 4 & 5. Barrowmaze is a sweet spot in between, good art, nicely...
  4. S

    D&D 5E (2014) Would You Let a Monk Roll for Stats?

    IME Monks are fine, I don't give them any extra powers or stats.
  5. S

    D&D 5E (2014) Would You Let a Monk Roll for Stats?

    I wouldn't let one player roll while making the rest use point buy. Some games the players roll, some they use point buy. Monks certainly favour/benefit from high rolls more than most classes.
  6. S

    D&D 5E (2024) How long should a Short rest be in 5E(2024)?

    I like the 5 minute 'catch your breath' SR best.
  7. S

    Slaine RPG from Mongoose Publishing

    I think I gave my Slaine RPG book away years ago, sorry! I've been adding Skull Swords in my 5e D&D game, as I recall I use MM Thug stats as the base. I bought the Warlord Games Skull Sword minis & a friend has been painting them.
  8. S

    What etiquette rules do we assume is common in the community?

    We do have a player who's vegetarian, but it's because of what he saw as a first responder to the 7/7 Underground massacre.
  9. S

    How I'd fix Star Wars

    I think the only really incompetent Imperial in the original trilogy is Grand Moff Tarkin, plus Vader with his plan that seemed deliberately intended to get rid of Tarkin and his Technological Terror - let the Rebels escape with the Death Star plans then follow them to Yavin with the compromised...
  10. S

    How I'd fix Star Wars

    General Veers seemed competent to me. He had a job and he did it! We are not shown many operational details, but a successful ground assault without air cover is usually not easy. Pity the navy as usual failed to interdict properly.
  11. S

    D&D Movie/TV D&D Movie Hit or Flop?

    The MCU already needed a several year breather after Endgame in 2019, say 3-4 years. They'd already messed up by not giving that, but Covid and their reaction to Covid exacerbated it I think.
  12. S

    D&D 5E (2014) Free 60+ page Guide to Sword & Sorcery for 5E D&D

    There's a lot of material on xoth.net statted for Legend - been using it for Dragonbane which is also BRP derived.
  13. S

    D&D Movie/TV D&D Movie Hit or Flop?

    I thought it was co-made by Hasbro's in house movie studio who they then sold off?
  14. S

    D&D Movie/TV D&D Movie Hit or Flop?

    That's really very not good and indicates a sizable loss on the production, as others have said. Is your metric for 'total flop' a film that does not even gross its production budget?
  15. S

    How I'd fix Star Wars

    I used to think that... but now I think he was making the officer think he was choking.
  16. S

    D&D General Where do New DMs Go for Help Online?

    No, I think Justin is often abrasive in eg his blog comments; pretty much wherever he's dealing with other people. His blog posts & videos are not aggressive though. I'm not actually aware of why he got booted from here; but getting actually-banned from ENW does generally take a fair amount of...
  17. S

    How I'd fix Star Wars

    Hm. I'd love a super-retro reboot of Star Wars based off the original Ralph Maquarrie (sp?) artwork - stormtroopers with shields et al. I feel there was a lot implied in the original film & novel that was never followed up on, as the series went in a different direction. Eg the Force wasn't...
  18. S

    D&D General Where do New DMs Go for Help Online?

    You won't see any hate in Macris's videos or blogs. He comes across quite sweet and extremely mild* mannered, zero Milo-style trolling. He's definitely a hardcore simulationist though. *The opposite of Justin Alexander in that regard; they seem political opposites too. I like them both.
  19. S

    How I'd fix Star Wars

    It's on amazon prime, I just watched the first 30 minutes, right now they're on a beach escaping from amazons chased by a very jerky giant amazon robot-golem based on Talos from Jason & the Argonauts. :LOL:
  20. S

    D&D General Where do New DMs Go for Help Online?

    Alexander is definitely extremely abrasive!
Top