Search results

Sure. I agree. My post was meant to say that whatever Keith is doing has next to no impact over whether I would still want a Daggerheart version of Eberron. For clarity: boy would I.

Military Urban Fantasy is about as close as I can get, but I will totally run that game.

Okay. i'm pretty sure we are talking more about genre classification.

The shake out happened pretty early on, though. What's the old addage? Science Fiction has a rocket ship on the cover, and fantasy has a dragon? Despite fuzzy genre lines, I think anyone can look at Spelljammer and see that it is purely fantastical, with no real "scince" elements at all, even...

That is the real "Vancian."

From Earth to the Moon. Space 1889. Treasure Planet. it is a real genre that has been around for a long time.

It seemed to suggest that you can in fact just start there, but then reiterate that getting there is the main barrier.

I like this. What, I wonder, are the kinds of high level campaigns that would require some rules forking? Domain management (and, one assumes, war). Becoming and/or fighting gods or other epic level entities. SAVE THE WORLD. And we should make room for Just More Adventures But In Ever Weirder...

These statements seem at odds.

I mean, Space Fantasy is right there... But, yeah, it is just a peeve. I don't expect the world to move for me.

If it were up to me, I would like a dedicated High level handbook with all those discussions and rules material, then a bunch of one page adventure and encounter seeds, and maybe a singular high level "one shot" to put all the pieces together.

Man I wish people would stop calling Spelljammer "sci fi."

I agree, but there could still be more support for GMs. Show them how to make effective high level encounters that are fun and engaging. Talk about what kinds of challenges become trivialized by different kinds of high level abilities, and how to use those high level abilities instead of nerfing...

We could just start with most of Brandon Sanderson's work. Most of his stuff is high fantasy powered fantasy by any definition. In fact, im a little suspect of WoT being on your low power fantasy list. As I recall, there's world shaking power in the hands of the protagonist and villain.

Are we still just going off the earlier thread numbers or is there something more recent. These books are all intended to be evergreen, so how they have sold since publication, up to and including today, matters if we really want to talk about them this way.

I think the real answer is to have a D&D "latin" -- that is, a lingua franca among lore keepers, going back millenia.

I don't buy that. There's easily just as much high powered fantasy out there.

One of the benefits to WotC of have a slow release schedule is that even the mediocre stuff "sells well." If you want official content, your choices are limited.

Maybe. It is also one of the most divisive. I think it was a great toolbox and a garbage adventure, but others obviously disagree.

Do you think he is just remaking Eberron with the serial numbers filed off? Because if not, your rebuttal makes very little sense.