Search results

His last video was somewhat critical of them, but not for the reason you think of

is the DM’s ‘I do not like tortles in my game’ as good a reason as the player’s ‘I would like to play a tortle’? I guess that is where we disagree this we agree on ;)

Don't know enough about the game, are Skaven a playable race or more like the Draconians in DL? Also, I am not seeing anything here that I would not consider personal preference. I'd lump that into like / do not like.

So far we basically got ‘because I like playing a tortle / TMNT / Master Oogway’ and ‘because I don’t like tortles’ (let’s face it, if you did, they would not be on the banned list) as the main reasons. Unless one side has a more convincing reason (not sure it exists, but I am open to the...

yes, they could do that too, that does not make their (potentially unacceptable) proposal an insult however

you might only find that there is no compromise possible once you had a bit of back and forth. The DM does not want tortles and suggests something that they think might preserve enough of the concept while fitting the setting, the player thinks that suggestion misses something important and...

I am not going to count the number of blades of grass or leaves on a tree I need to defile for a fireball. The knowledge that it happens is sufficient, mechanics make this tedious I agree insofar as it should not be a subclass ;)

I'd still call a tree a plant. That it does not appear in the MM is due to the fact that people so rarely get beaten up by scrubs and trees that they are not worth mentioning - we do have tree blights and treants for the rare cases this happens

does it matter whether this is a published setting or someone’s homebrew? I also doubt most players read through the FR Campaign Setting book or whatever its equivalent is for another setting, so ‘shared’ really means the two page summary by the DM

so in your world there is no grass on the hills, flowers in the meadows, trees in forests, etc., or do you call those something other than plants?

but not every input is an improvement either

they are not entitled to it, no, which is why the player has the choice to accept or decline

never heard of them. There are Dargonesti that live in the sea, but they do not want to flood the surface, they are peaceful and isolationist are you sure this even is DL?

no, just a regular elf living on the surface like ‘everyone else’

after the first few pages it had veered off topic anyway, hard

yeah, that makes it pretty comparable to 5e for me, I don't think I will ever go past level 14 or so anyway

which 5e level does DH level 10 correspond to?

it helps that you get the full digital releases if you have been a patreon long enough to cover the price (i.e. if the product costs $24 digital, you need to have been a patreon the last three months, as the patreon is $8 per month). If they stick to their timeline this gets you all PDFs from...

Did they say who takes over as Lead Designer? I believe Teos Abadia is taking the lead on Crack the Sun, but that might not be the same thing

at least as frequent as the GM not even trying to compromise and simply saying ‘these are your options, pick one’ that some people claim happened. Not going through the thread for dozens of posts to quote. I would have said at least @Remathilis and @GobHag, but apparently for the former that...