Search results

  1. MGibster

    D&D (2024) Is Combat Tedious on Purpose?

    Yeah, it's a contentious title, but we're living in a post-social media world where click bait titles are how you get views. But let's start from the beginning. Is combat in 5th edition tedious? After a few weeks of running it with the players moving from levels 1 through 4, I can safely say...
  2. MGibster

    D&D (2024) Do We Really Need Levels 11-20?

    I've seen various sources saying most D&D campaigns end by the time the characters are between levels 7-10. Assuming this is true, why bother with levels 11-20? Okay, I get it. Assuming most campaigns go no higher than 10, there are still some people who do have campaigns that go that high...
  3. MGibster

    D&D (2024) Druid w/ Pet Dinosaur - Help Me Build Character

    I have a player with a character concept a bit outside the norm. He's playing a Druid, and his intention is to have a pet animal that does the direct fighting while he sits in the back and casts supportive spells. If you've ever played World of Warcraft, this sounds an awful lot like one of...
  4. MGibster

    In Praise of Engaged Players

    My long term group has faced some challenges the last few years with two people moving to another country and one moving into hospice. Player A went ahead and recruited two of his board gaming buddies, players B and C. Players B and C weren't bad people, but they really weren't all that...
  5. MGibster

    D&D (2024) Help Me Hate Monks (Less Than I Currently Do)

    I am to Monks as Snarf is to Bards. And just so we're clear, I have an intense dislike for them in the context of most D&D settings. I rather like them in places like Legend of the Five Rings or Kar-Tur. It's like someone tried to shoehorn Kwai Chang Caine from Kung-Fu* into D&D and it's...
  6. MGibster

    D&D (2024) Rewarding PCs with Unbalancing Power

    I'm about to start a 5th edition Greyhawk campaign. In the first scenario, the PCs take on an organization, the Ordo Ventricula Sanctus, a group of villainous monks dedicated to becoming one with the universe through gastronomical exploration. The PCs should run across one of their storage...
  7. MGibster

    D&D General How Do D&D Adventurers Dress?

    Let's get this out of the way. Of course it depends on the setting, the PCs culture, and what they do for a living. But how are they dressed compared to the average person in the campaign? In the default D&D campaign, the player characters are adventurers, or weirdos as I like to call them...
  8. MGibster

    What Happened to RPG Outreach/Ambassador Programs Run by Companies?

    So back in the 1990s and the early 2000s, there were a few RPG companies who had their own outreach/ambassador programs. This was basically a system where volunteers would run a company's games at store events or conventions and in exchange they'd get free stuff or other considerations. There...
  9. MGibster

    Effective Communication Outside of Game Play

    I ran a campaign recently that was not to the liking of one of my players. Instead of talking to me about it directly, he had his character behave in a disruptive manner just to stir the pot, he made passive aggressive complaints, and when he had to replace his character introduced a new one...
  10. MGibster

    Best Horror Role Playing Game

    We've currently got a thread going ranking the best horror movies of all time. Let's talk about the best horror RPGs of all time. Criteria? Look, I don't really like to get bogged down in discussions of what is or isn't horror. If you want to tell me Burrows & Bunnies is a horror game...
  11. MGibster

    D&D (2024) Treasure in D&D 2024

    D&D has almost always had an adventure treadmill. Characters go adventuring, they gain experience and treasure, become more powerful, and go out to repeat the whole process until they run out of levels. Good times. Way back in the old days, you you needed to spend your hard earned gold to...
  12. MGibster

    D&D General Help Me with My Pathological Aversion to Third Party D&D Products

    I have a pathological aversion to third party products designed to be compatible with D&D. When I go to the local game store, if I'm considering a product for use with D&D I won't look at anything that hasn't been published by WotC. I say it's a pathological aversion because my most favorite...
  13. MGibster

    D&D General The Disappearance of D&D from Mainstream Retailers

    I'm old, but I'm not that old, so I don't really know where people were buying D&D back in the 1970s. By the early 1980s, AD&D products were available through mainstream retailers. You could go to the mall and find AD&D books at Kaybee Toy, B. Dalton Booksellers, and I don't know if Sears...
  14. MGibster

    D&D General Multiclassing Shouldn't be Treated as the Default

    A relatively minor complaint I have about 5th edition is having to wait until third level to get my subslcass. In a few of the D&D campaigns I've run, players have wanted to skip to level three because "that's when it gets fun." One of the reasons we wait until third level to get our subclass...
  15. MGibster

    Game Design: Acquiring Equipment as Part of Game Play

    Once upon a time, in a kingdom far, far away, lived a little boy who really enjoyed poring over equipment lists, especially those with dozens upon dozens of polearms, deciding how best to spend my gold on equipment. Lucerne hammer or glaive. You better believe Lucerne. I don’t have enough for a...
  16. MGibster

    Players Don't Care About Your Setting

    It pains me to say this, but I don't think most players care about game settings all that much. It pains me to admit this because I'm someone who really loves settings, and who chooses what games to run primarily based on how much I like the setting (I'm not looking at you Shadowrun). Most...
  17. MGibster

    Annual Horror Thread for Halloween (Spooky Gaming)

    If Home Depot, Michael's, At Home, and other retail outlets can start selling Halloween stuff in August then it's not too early to talk about horror gaming now! All Hallows' Eve is the time to tell ourselves scary stories and drink a lot of beer according to the National Beer Wholesalers...
  18. MGibster

    The Grand Grimoire of Cthulhu Mythos Magic (A Review)

    The Grand Grimoire of Cthulhu Mythos Magic (Review – Call of Cthulhu) The Grand Grimoire of Cthulhu Mythos Magic is a compilation of some 550+ spells appearing through the myriads of Call of Cthulhu sourcebooks, supplements, and scenarios published over a period of time spanning more than...
  19. MGibster

    Arkham: Review Call of Cthulhu Sourcebook

    Arkham is a sandbox campaign setting for use with the Call of Chtulhu role playing games set during the 1920s. A fictional town created by author H.P. Lovecraft as a setting for his stories, Arkham, Massachusetts is located roughly 23 miles north of Boston on the banks of the equally fictional...
  20. MGibster

    Horror and Headstone Hill (Deadland Campaign Review w/ Spoilers)

    The Horror at Headstone Hill is an investigative campaign for Deadlands using the Savage Worlds rules. For those unfamiliar with Deadlands, the game is set in the Old West of the United States but with a twist including magic, steampunk, and horror. Dubbed “The Weird West,” this is a game where...
Top