Search results

  1. Anon Adderlan

    Social Encounters: Does it Matter What and How PCs Speak to NPCs?

    By rendering what/how PCs speak meaningless you invalidate a player's social acumen and force them to rely on their mechanical acumen, which completely changes what the game is about and which skillset gives you the edge. This is why we have different games which meet different needs, and why I...
  2. Anon Adderlan

    MCDM Update: The Power Roll

    Sooo they dropped an entire 20 min video on how they changed the die roll mechanics. Again. And what they came up with... is the same mechanics PbtA has been using for the last decade. This has reached the point of parody, and I get the idea the team is more enamored with developing a game than...
  3. Anon Adderlan

    Playing in the Blank Spaces of the System

    RPGs are ultimately just a set of tools and procedures, so it makes perfect sense to use them to facilitate the parts of play you would not otherwise address by simply playing. You don't need a social system when you can rely on your own personality at the table. Likewise you don't need a combat...
  4. Anon Adderlan

    Planet of the Apes Roleplaying Game Coming from Magnetic Press

    The entire premise revolves around biological essentialism, and just because future apes have a caste system doesn't mean it's a good thing. While this would be my preference as well, it still doesn't eliminate the themes of biological essentialism.
  5. Anon Adderlan

    WotC Hasbro CEO optimistic about AI in D&D and MTG’s future

    It's no accident that #PeppaPig was mentioned in the same breath as D$D as #Hasbro's plans are the same for both: generating content on demand. They have all the media they'll ever need to train with, so they don't need to hire anyone. The results don't need to make sense, as the audience won't...
  6. Anon Adderlan

    Launch of gaming news site, Rascal

    So I subbed to give it a proper evaluation and add some commentary. Let's see where things are in a month. Yes, that's my point. #Rascal on the other hand does. Because hypotheticals are my specialty, I'm familiar with the media industry, new businesses almost inevitably trip over the same...
  7. Anon Adderlan

    Pathfinder 2E By prohibiting ORC licensing on Pathfinder/Starfinder Infinite, Paizo is now a step closer to WotC's walled garden approach with dmsguild

    So this issue came up on my search for ORC info, yet apparently neither #Google nor #Bing properly indexed this thread, so I had to invoke site search to finish the job. I thought this too, but truth is your derived mechanics are only licensed under ORC if you include the explicit declaration...
  8. Anon Adderlan

    The DUNE RPG

    I dropped a superchat on #QuinnsIdeas' livestream breakdown of the film, though I'm not sure how much more obnoxious I should be about it. I'm sure there's a huge segment of the #Dune fandom who would be interested in but are completely unaware of this.
  9. Anon Adderlan

    Win Up to $2K In Chaosium's Design Challenge

    After reading both the ORC license and FAQ I'm apparently completely wrong, as it requires an explicit license statement: III. Required Notice. The grant of this ORC License to You is expressly conditioned on You including the notice statements described in subsections (a)–(d) below in a...
  10. Anon Adderlan

    Fun Kickstarter Stats

    Do you have any data on how the duration of the campaign affects things?
  11. Anon Adderlan

    Stormlight rpg

    Perhaps a tad ;) More like #HarryPotter territory. You forget the part where people tend not to buy outside their fandom, slow their purchasing of alternatives when committed to a multi-year campaign, and the indie market tends to exchange the same $1 among themselves. And yet creators are...
  12. Anon Adderlan

    Launch of gaming news site, Rascal

    To be clear I'm in the "I want to believe" camp as I'm dreading the inevitable information dark age we're facing. This is why I'm being critical as opposed to ignoring it entirely. I wouldn't be so sure, especially when the quarterbacks are experienced in an industry and have different...
  13. Anon Adderlan

    Stormlight rpg

    Yeah, I'd suggest everyone get their crowdfunding out of the way before it hits as it's likely to take all the oxygen out of the room for years after.
  14. Anon Adderlan

    Launch of gaming news site, Rascal

    Again, what value are they adding beyond what places like #DiceBreaker already provide? Journalists who want to focus on journalism. I'm not, as plenty of professionals have no idea what they're doing outside their particular niche. And why would anyone pay to comment there when they could...
  15. Anon Adderlan

    Win Up to $2K In Chaosium's Design Challenge

    So technically you don't even need to produce a game, merely present a compelling pitch, and you retain all rights to your work regardless. The winnings are too small to justify anything other than paying yourself or a single artist however. I warned folks that the #ORC license would bite...
  16. Anon Adderlan

    James Introcaso talks about the Power Roll, a change to the MCDM resolution system.

    I have no problem with funding prior to completed design. It can be an effective strategy, and in some cases the only one practically available. However the fact anyone thought this minor change was worthy of an update doesn't give me much faith in the process. And it not only implies the...
  17. Anon Adderlan

    Launch of gaming news site, Rascal

    Right now it's essentially a hybrid blog and mailing list, but I'm still not seeing the value proposition. I mean how is this meaningfully different from something like #DiceBreaker which already provides far more? Honestly they'd be far better off simply running a #Patreon.
  18. Anon Adderlan

    Launch of gaming news site, Rascal

    So the last 'article' I spotted there was a ZWEIHÄNDER Reforged press release, and the RPG.NET merger interview was hidden behind a subscription wall, free though it may be. If they intend to present press releases in this manner and hide actual reporting behind subscriptions they're going to...
  19. Anon Adderlan

    Critical Role's 'Daggerheart' Open Playtest Starts In March

    If the system avoids explicitly ordering player turns I can see how it would give them more tactical leeway and opportunities to cooperate, as the mechanics will make sure it becomes the GM's turn eventually.
Top