Search results

A minute seems bonkers to me for a skirmish melee - I imagine DND combat more like a riot than organised battle lines. I could see it used for one on one combat maybe, but for archery it would fall apart. I've done combat sports for years and time really slows down for you, so ten seconds is a...

Everything that is a game mechanic does not reflect our reality: HP, rounds, turns, combat rolls, abilities, etc. They are all just gamist abstractions or they stimulate DND reality. We're just used to them and have internalised all the weird inconstancies.

Not our reality though, its own DND reality. Nothing in DND stands up to any scrutiny.

Can you not go back to the 5.14 fighter in that case? You might need a little house rule boost from the DM to make up for the slight power escalation from 5.24, but thats game/group dependent I'd imagine. But your post has the opposite effect on me. Making me think how to juice more 4e fighter...

And that brouhaha was always stupid. The DMs job there was to mesh the narrative to the mechanical, if it matters to the group, and its so straightforward to do that: "your attack (effect whatever) creates a resonance wave in the jelly, causing it to wobble, destablising it." Same mechanical...

Bloody Tongue ended by dynamite.

No its from a youtube video of someone who did a page by page thing. Someone captured each page and into a PDF. From the screenshot posted its low quality and there is a watermark from the youtuber.

Unfortunately someone has already screen scraped one of the videos before it was taken down and their is a PDF out there. It was going to happen anyway I suppose due to the interest. I doubt it will seriously affect their sales though.

Undecided. I don't think there are enough changes here to make me enthusiastic about running 5e. My current schedule is to run Temple of Elemental Evil in 2025 for my group and I've had a request from a player to use 5.5e for this, so I might just have to bite the bullet and make it work.

I gave a few examples in my previous post. But drawing on skeletons as monsters like they are scary maybe a fear effect/aura. They are connected to death so maybe death saves are worse when they are around. Bones are brittle so maybe maybe each hit disables a limb and they keep coming like...

I disagree, bags of hitpoints are mostly pointless IMO. Each monster should have something unique about it, and passive stuff like vulnerabilities usually don't count. There is nothing in that description that says Skeleton Minotaur for me, just Minotaur.

The should have brought in Hidden as a condition rather than reused Invisibility. Used that for the mundane and the other for the magical.

Yeah I'm sure they could have spiced it up a little; you get bone shard splinters on a fumble or bone dust lung disease. Or you get Necrotic Plague from the dark energies that animate them if you fight them more than 5 rounds. E: the picture is the most exciting part!!

Pretty boring apart from the Flaming Skeleton. Warhorse and Minotaur are a little pointless as the skeletony part does little or nothing.

This reminds me of when City of the Spider Queen broke me as a DM and I swore off 3.x DND for a long time.

I listen to 3d6 Down the Line podcast and in a recent episode they were fighting a high level undead cleric, a Mummy and a few Shadows. That combat took an hour and a half of the podcast, with one character death. They are in a Mega-dungeon complex and follow the process for B/X (OSE really)...

Yeah 4e needed a proper 4.5 to smooth down some of the grit in the system and debloat it somewhat. Paring it down and running a customised version so you can get non-tactically minded players to manage their down sheets is a must as well. It needs to be released with a proper SRD so the 4e...

In 4e I usually "zoom out" to some extent, treat each dungeon area with an encounter budget with notable features, and let them wander around in it and if combat happens then the whole area can be involved. Or if there are interesting features they can interact with them, a group stealth check...

Slight aside: the hobo part of murderhobo refers to the pcs generally having no real fixed abode or wandering around to different locations doing odd jobs - usually murdering..

Lots of good perspectives here, thanks everyone: 13th Age would be a goer. I even got the humble bundle recently. And I think it would be a good fit for my Temple of Elemental Evil (Pulp Action Style). I might have put too much on the trick part of the story. I'd be more reskinning 4e to fit...