Search results

  1. S

    Healing during a short rest with leader healing

    I'm ruling that the cleric can use whatever healing words are remaining from the previous encounter, and afterwards he must also rest and cannot continue to utilize this. 4E has gone out of its way to eliminate ridiculous over-inflation of this sort of bookkeeping. It annoyed me on the very...
  2. S

    Combat takes too long

    My group's rounds are much faster, and the overall combat is shorter as well. We completed 3 combat encounters and a skill challenge last week during our normal playing time. In 3E we wouldn't have completed all three combats that quickly. Also, seems like you might be missing some strikers...
  3. S

    Developer Talk = Gospel?

    I remember a game I dungeon mastered where one of my players was a conjurer/summoner, and managed to get something like 7 elementals into the fight before the end. His final turn took him like 10 minutes to complete. Sure, those summoning ideas can be a cool mechanic, but they just totally bog...
  4. S

    Judicious use and description of Minions [Edit-Now asking for stat analysis]

    I personally use minions in the same way they are used in action movies. Everybody knows Darth Vader isn't hiding in with the stormtroopers wearing similar white armor. He's the BBEG in the back with the dark black armor and clearly above and beyond the other monsters. I think, that do do...
  5. S

    D&D 4E Favorite 4E classes(all)

    I love the warlord. I'm just drawn in by its superior tactical choices, and all the cool things I can do to manipulate the battlefield "facts on the ground". Too bad I'm the DM currently, bah! My first character in a game will definitely be a human Warlord.
  6. S

    D&D 3E/3.5 Help me break my 3e addiction: NPCs with levels

    DMG page 184 has all the tools you need to make the npc. Core Statistics: 1) Type: Fighter would be a soldier. 2) Assign Stats: I'll use normal numbers: Str 18, Con 14, Dex 13, Int 12, Wis 11, Cha 10 2) Hit Points (Soldier) = 8+Con+(level*8) = 182 hit points. 3) AC: level+16 = 36 4) Defenses...
  7. S

    In substantial monsters hit point totals.

    Well I guess I'm just going to remove 2xlevel hit points from all insubstantials that I make in the future, that should be a reasonable approximation of the unknown mechanic behind their hit point totals. I tend to adjust monsters to fit my needs most of the time, so I am constantly making...
  8. S

    Loot question

    It's probably a rod like the warlocks rod, worth 12 gold (Arcane Implement - Rod, PHB 222).
  9. S

    In substantial monsters hit point totals.

    Clearly, but what is the exact mechanic that is being utilized to reduce their hp? I don't recognize a specific formula addendum that is influencing this, just the obvious, which is that they have less hp. I want to know how much less I need to account for when making or adjusting...
  10. S

    In substantial monsters hit point totals.

    I've noticed that insubstantial monsters have significantly less hit points than the rules would ordinarily dictate. Examples: a) Ghost - Phantom Warrior (MM 116). Level 5 soldiers (48 hp) with con 12, they should have 52 hp, but they only have 40 - same total as their type minus...
  11. S

    Cleave - Automatic hits on 2nd target?

    Why exactly would either of the following happen? 1) The DM puts minions with another monster with vastly different AC? This is unlikely to happen unless the minions was way lower in level than the other monster, and likely way lower in level than the fighter. Either way, the minions do not...
  12. S

    Armor Proficiency prerequisites

    1) I don't believe there is any way that you can lose attribute points in 4E. 2) Wearing the armor does not require the 15 Str and Con, only taking the feat. Paladins do not need the feat, they automatically are proficient with that armor type, hence no, you do not need a 15 Str and Con to...
  13. S

    Do the players get to know what number they got hit with?

    Characters should be aware how closely they came to being hit, or how closely they came to avoiding the attack. When you drive your car and almost hit another car, you know it. I think hiding the numbers from players isn't very constructive or make much sense. The podcast DM annoyed me by...
  14. S

    Do the players get to know what number they got hit with?

    I always tell my players the monster's AC, and also my attack roll numbers, and I tend to make special note of barely missed ot hit attacks ("The hobgoblin's attack barely passes beyond your shield to nick you..I hit with a 15", "You get your shield up just in time, and barely deflect the...
  15. S

    Multiclass feat question

    Feats will state if you can take them multiple times. In the case of the power-swap multiclass feats, the answer is no, you cannot take them more than once.
  16. S

    I'm now confuzzled.

    Feint (bluff) in combat grants combat advantage, you don't need to roll stealth after a Feint. Create a Diversion (Bluff) in combat can be used to distract the enemy (enemies are normally only distracted when not in combat - in combat they are observing all around them) to allow you to hide...
  17. S

    My warlock wants to stab you in the eye!

    I'd suggest you instead try to learn some critical thinking skills - this is a pretty unambiguous rule unless you're trying to be gamey and create yourself an exploit. Deleted--please remember the rules of the site include the "no politics" rules. I'd also suggest that you try to learn some...
  18. S

    Cloud of Darkness vs Light: which wins?

    There was like a three page discussion of this just yesterday. I swear, I think someone adds a thread on this topic and whether people use hex grids instead of squares, like every day.
  19. S

    My warlock wants to stab you in the eye!

    PHB page 294: Don't Add Together: If you get temporary hit points from different sources, use the higher value as your temporary hit point total instead of adding the values together. Seems pretty clear cut to me, never add temporary hit points together. Never. Add. Together. Always take...
  20. S

    Do Monsters know about a Fighter's Combat Challenge?

    The blast would just mark all the opponents for one round, and yeah, I'd say that gets their attention if the fighter is mocking and taunting them, and is a close and serious threat. They are aware of his intentions and it impacts their capabilities. The web spell, aside from the initial...
Top