Search results

Good question. Why limit your potential for the next day because you used a lot of HD today, especially when you can just long rest and fully heal? My guess is because they made long rests kinda silly with a full heal already. They should have changed that instead of making short rest healing...

DM once in a while, play mostly. Our group has 3 DMs and we rotate out.

They are allowed to try. If they are not in a safe place, it will not likely be successful, and I have warned my players that's how my game works.

What you do is take out the first target, go unnoticed and have combat end, and then surprise the next target by starting combat again. Once combat starts and enemies are aware it started, they can no longer be assassinated because there is no surprise until combat ends. Surprise would not...

Lots of work on Google Docs, either at home or work.

You can talk under water, but it's not very clear. With a bit of practice, this is easy to do. If you can breathe underwater, there should be no restriction. I allow my players to cast under water if they make a concentration check, but if they fail they lose the slot.

I think the druid is very strong to start with, and then needs some help at later levels. The warlock seems like it could use some love - at least some variation from EB.

I used to love XP too. Milestones are much better, the DM just has to plan out when that happens and stick to it. Our other two DMs frequently forget, and ask what level we are. lol. Milestones are fair and balanced, and happen between sessions, which is good for DM planning.

No. I have been toying around with the idea of using a small hourglass timer, but haven't pulled the trigger yet. If I come up with a situation like the walls are closing in, then I might actually do it.

We try to play every week, but that turns out to about half if you look at a whole year of playing. We have been doing this very consistently for the last 15 years or so, plus lots of random play before that. Pretty sure I have well over 600. I have been playing D&D since '77, but it's hard...

Yes. They are a yardstick to see how much can be accomplished before being forced to rest. There's always something to do, and the constraints of the room layout make for interesting tactics. Not remembering why you are there is not the dungeon crawl's fault. That requires good note...

In my game, it's an automatic kill unless it's someone high level/important. Advantage on an attack seems ridiculous when you could plunge your dagger in their throat without any resistance. I would not make a player roll to hit in situations like that. If the creature is not humanoid, there...

I've found that my enjoyment in playing is not the edition of the game. It's hanging out with friends and having a good time.

I use alignment in the games I run as a roleplaying guideline. It does not control/dictate how you must act. If you act outside of your alignment, it may change it, but that has little impact in the game.

I miss it immensely when someone plays a barbarian halfling/gnome with an 18 strength. The level of ridiculousness is epic.

Depends on if there is a chance they get to play and who's fault it is they are separated.

Balance to me means that each player can contribute to the game and feel good about their contribution. This of course varies from player to player and how they like to play the game. One player should not get all the lime light by say, dominating combat. As DM, it's my job to appropriately...

In Session 0, explain that the characters are from the city, and care about the city. Center the quests and adventure around the city, and bettering it. Have several important NPCs in the city, and one that notably likes the party, and can help them out. If you set up that the characters are...

That's cool if you run it differently than the rules. I would suggest adding that it is a house rule next time, so it's not confusing. With that omission, it came across as required RAW.

Nope. I really like the old core races, and find all the others rather unappealing.