Search results

:) First of all i hope everyone understood that what i formerly wrote is only about the melee attack itself is part of the twin effect. I honestly didnt intent to try telling people how to do read it. My point in general was that There are two ways of Reading it, and many seems very subjective...

No not the same - find me an example where you Can twin something that is not spell... the other example you mention are directly texted as spells... if you Can find me one example where you Can twin something that is not texted as being spell then i say you are right - untill then its more...

I know this qoute and i also refered to it earlier about him stating that the twin mechanism would work. That doesnt mean the non magic melee is Twinned. Please try and find me any other example of any possible spell that Can be Twinned where it is twinning something that doesnt have directly...

Thats one Way of Reading it, but you cant be objective in this discussion so lets just Call it. You have narrowed it Down to what you believe, and i dont say you are wrong i just say that it Can also be read directly differently amd that Crawford havent commented on that part about the melee...

I never Said you couldnt twin the spell of boomingblade... I just say you cant twin the melee part, well more likely i say it Can be read on two ways that you cant and that you Can depending on how you want to understand the content. And if you dont agree on that then lets just agree to...

Noone never Said it couldnt be Twinned - the discussion is if the melee part is Twinned or not - the spell attack is Twinned noone disagree on that cause we all know Crawford confirmed that - Eg. The link you provided.

You are so wrong. The melee part according to sages compendium is not part of the magic regardless if the magic forces you to do so The twin spell only affect spells Booming Blade consist of two fases melee attack and spell attack The melee is Per written rules not part of the spell and is...

Twinned spell is part of a specific spell action... Now i Will simplify it to explain Why it you cant twin the melee of booming Bode An action When casting a spell you dont use your action unless the casting time is the same as an action... i hope we Can agree on this...? When casting...

No boomingblade blade say “As part of the action used to cast this spell...” so its part of the combined action, its not an individual spell or anything that Can be twinned - when twin spelling you dont get to use an additional action therefore its impossible to argue directly on the text that...

I dont Think anyone would say you cant twin spell boomingblade - the thing people seems to have different opinions about is the melee attack. It States in boomingblade that a melee attack is needed for the spell, not two or three of Four etc. So regardless how many times and actions you...

I agree That it is cantrip/spell action and npt attack action a but the text says directly “as part of the action”... you dont use an additional action to twincast which mean that directly if you take into consideration what the working say you only gonna do one melee hit- the twin spell dont...

There can be argued by that its possible but also that it is not: Possible: Does the spell effect only one? Yes it does which mean that no doub't the twinned spell works and it should work. Is the melee attack a magic attack, well its used in the cantrip action so it cant be regular attack...