Search results

Id say that the biggest problem is that the dmg section quoted by @Maxperson really only applies to tier1 PCs and breaks down as players move through tier2 into tier 3 levels. Take the monk & warlock as the prime examples designed to enable 5mwd loops. The monk has a ki pool growing equal to...

Why go from actively ignoring it as a thing even deserving a footnote to asking how many I would allow?Would you not agree that the rules should provide some support the gm in such a thing if they are expected to handle that for the system?I'll answer your question with a call for you to supply...

Why do you think short rests deserve such a pass in service of enabling the short rest class nova loop? All such a section would do is embolden short rest class players who already feel like they should expect ultra regular short rests to fuel endless nova. Wotc's refusal to do or say anything...

Are you asserting that such monsters npcs & so on always have the spell prepared so they can burn a 3rd level slot to dispel the ritually casted LTH before the players complete their rest?

If you were to make a hypothetical list of monsters capable of dispelling leonunds invincible bunker, what percentage of the monster manual would you guess could do that? Without cross referencing I'd guess that it is a single digit percentage & would not be surprised if that percentage was...

L I'm going to say that you're example rings pretty hollow. I've seen more than one group where the wizard refuses to choose LTH only for a monk/warlock/fighter to go out searching for a source to buy§ the scroll for LTH from -and- gave the wizard coin to scribe it. I've also been that wizard...

A few people spoke positively about spell point variants. I've played with and run games that used it occasionally since the 3.x days(iirc it's default in the 3.x dead lands fork). At no point have I ever seen it result in anything but casters burning all spell points on repeat casting of...

Huh? 5e cantrips are unlimited at will powers that don't use spell slots like old school equivalents. All of those magic slings and xbows exited because casters really got a huge benefit from them. They weren't prized without good reason. Unlimited cantrips are one of the reasons it's...

I wouldn't agree with that bolded bit because of how it actually played at the table. Classes either fell into one of two buckets. Either they had far more spells they could choose from while doing prep (ie wizard and cleric due to spell book and how divine prep worked) or they were like...

Looks like we were making similar points at the same time. Although the trouble is that shifting from vancian prep to 5e's flexible neovancian prep results in a wildly expanded array of available spells and slots on any given turn.

I think that the problem is to some degree less a matter of how many than how flexible they have become under 5e's neo vancian prep. If you look at the old slot progression tables in past editions casters tended to have more total spell slots at just about every level and a tighter spell...

No it's what you actually suggested because I've been talking about short rest nova loops and you keep quoting me ignoring that particular detail while inserting long rest stuff to defend the dual rest/recovery cycle short rest class design in a long rest attrition adventuring day based game

I think that bolded bit is really central to the root of the problem. You can see how obviously responsible it is by looking at how often people defending the system provided gm toolset available drift back to 8hr long rest & long rest classes while 1hr short rests & short rest classes come...

That was so much the case that iirc early AL "seasons" when "dm reward points" were a bad idea still in use offered it offered playing an oathbreaker pc as one of the rewards an AL GM could choose.

My experience was pretty identical to @overgeeked . Most§ of my players were older millennials fellow xenniels genxrs and even a few boomers. Given the number of tables being run it shouldn't be particularly shocking that younger ply hooked up with younger gms (more than one of which has a...

I refuse to unpack this fisking but will say that Oathbreaker is a subclass on page 97 of the DMG. It may or mat not have fallen a bit in the rankings against some of the newer subclasses, but it's generally considered to be relatively powerful with an unusual set of subclass spells for a...

except that we live in a world where this is a reality When players come to the table to play a modern ttrpg already familiar with roleplaying games through their experience playing roleplaying games on their console/computer for years & the mechanics of the game encourage them to maintain the...

No because the GM needs to be able to hold credible problems or that bold bit only matters as far as players choose to allow it to impact every future scenario. "May be mechanical"? I was explicitly clear. WHAT are they since you assert they exist.