6 npc designer reviews at the same time

Status
Not open for further replies.
Why don't we just agree not to agree at this point, I even answered the last "why" above or in another thread at this point I am very unsure and the drama of all this has left a pretty bitter taste.

I have removed NPC Designer from being for sale here and this will end the matter all together for me. Have a nice holiday.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

Not taking a side here, but just noting that this whole discussion should be in meta so that I can keep track of it since it does have some pertinent ideas I think could be put in the reviews system such as the "was this review helpful" button.

So since this belongs in meta, off it goes -- swish --
 

Vascant said:
Why don't we just agree not to agree at this point, I even answered the last "why" above or in another thread at this point I am very unsure and the drama of all this has left a pretty bitter taste.

I have removed NPC Designer from being for sale here and this will end the matter all together for me. Have a nice holiday.

Vas, as I have already purchased NPC Designer, this does not directly affect me, but I still feel the need to speak out.

Removing NPC Designer from the ENWorld Store because of some knee-jerk reactions from members of the staff and a select few posters is a sad event.

One suggestion for the review system...if the staff wishes to delete reviews that don't meet their standards, I would recommend that ALL reviews are critiqued by the review board BEFORE being allowed to post to the forum. This little step would have saved a bunch of silly drama.
 


Vascant said:
Why don't we just agree not to agree at this point, I even answered the last "why" above or in another thread at this point I am very unsure and the drama of all this has left a pretty bitter taste.

I have removed NPC Designer from being for sale here and this will end the matter all together for me. Have a nice holiday.
I don't think its worth hurting thesells of your products over. Different strokes for different folks I say. Enworlds a big grouping of d and d nuts and this is the place to be if you're selling wares.

THink about it like this Vascant, you just went the D and D version of going public. That's a good thing. Sure people will talk about your stock, (in this case whether there's inflated buzz to drive up the stock price) and some people will praise the stock's performance (good reviews). From a marketing standpoint look at it like this, you're getting BUZZ. So long as you're not jumping on chairs you'll be fine ;). Try to stay away from arguments with gamers on here as that does make the product and company look bad. If I were you I wouldnt even comment. Let people comment about how great your product is and speculate while you rake in the doe.

I say keep the product on here, try to get it on drivethrunow and rpgnow next, get big, make people happy and upset and (i know its never been about the money with you) but get your product into every d and d home in this country, I think that this is possible. I havn't met one DM young or old, new or expert, whom havnt thought of the usefulness of theproduct.

But taking it off enworld is a step backwards. If someone thinks bad about your product oh well. Don't take your ball and go home, kick it over their fense and break a window.
 

DonTadow said:
But taking it off enworld is a step backwards. If someone thinks bad about your product oh well. Don't take your ball and go home, kick it over their fense and break a window.

exactly...
 

Vascant said:
I have removed NPC Designer from being for sale here and this will end the matter all together for me. Have a nice holiday.
I'll admit that I've mostly just skimmed this thread and I hadn't developed an opinion one way or the other, however this sort of Drama Queen action always tempts me to say "Don't let the door hit ya..."

-Dave
 


DonTadow said:
But taking it off enworld is a step backwards. If someone thinks bad about your product oh well. Don't take your ball and go home, kick it over their fense and break a window.
Yep.

The best commentary I've read is Monte Cook on Game Industry Etiquette. Attempting to defend the quality of a product is futile. Instead you should focus on correcting factual errors. Attempting to defend your intent or motives is probably even more futile.
 

There is no drama. It's never been about the quality of the product. Some of the reviews simply don't meet the minimum standard that Psion allows in the reviews database, mostly because of their length. Making it about anything more than that is a waste of time but doesn't actually create any drama. I don't know why anyone thinks there is any drama attached to this situation.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.
Remove ads

Top