For me, it is not so much everything by a particular director or writer, or a particular genre, it is more what happens to the main characters at the end of a movie. If all the main characters are killed off, then I won't rewatch it. If a main character is killed off just for the shock value, or as a "lesson" for the lead character, I won't watch it again. Rogue One is a good movie, but none of the main characters survived, so I won't watch it a second time. The first two Riddick movies are decent, but they kill off his co-star/love interest in a meaningless death at the end of both, just because they could, so I won't watch them again either. There are others that fit this theme, but those are the ones that always come to mind for me.