All Three 3.5 D&D Books in the Amazon Top 25!

[alleynbard]

Who on THIS thread did what you are saying?

Pay attention. I didn't accuse anyone here. I was simply giving an answer as to why Jack said what he said. I honestly don't know if any of you have done that.

But now that you mention it Kask, you started off in this thread insinuating that somehow this indicates 4e is failing and that you doubt the statements coming from Wizards.

 

[Kask]

But now that you mention it Kask, you started off in this thread insinuating that somehow this indicates 4e is somehow failing and that you doubt the statements coming from Wizards.

Umm, no. But nice try at trolling.

 

[alleynbard]

But even the person that originated the thread said it may have no significance. All this thread is doing is showing a point of interest.

I agree. But the moment someone tries to use this data as a valid indicator wouldn't you think the natural response would be "hypocrisy"?

 

[alleynbard]

Umm, no. But nice try at trolling.

I am hardly a troll Kask and you have established your feelings about Wizards and 4e quite completely on multiple threads.

What exactly do you call your first post? Was it not a insinuation that 4e is doing poorly and we are being lied to? What is it you are trying to say? I will even take your word for it. That is how trusting I am.

Try to answer the question intelligently and not fall back on the troll defense please.

 

[Jack99]

Who on THIS thread did what you are saying?

Become community supporter and find out! It's easy and it's fast, you get to support your favorite D&D website, and you never, ever have to ask this kind of questions again.



I am not going to name and point fingers. It rarely amounts to any fun. Come to think about it, this was probably a waste of time. Please feel free to disregard my previous posts in this thread. This one is not to be ignored though. Support ENworld!

Cheers

 

[alleynbard]

Become community supporter and find out! It's easy and it's fast, you get to support your favorite D&D website, and you never, ever have to ask this kind of questions again.



I am not going to name and point fingers. It rarely amounts to any fun. Come to think about it, this was probably a waste of time. Please feel free to disregard my previous posts in this thread. This one is not to be ignored though. Support ENworld!

Cheers

Good advice all around. If I had the money to do so, I would in a heart beat.

I will admit, not sure why I even posted here. I should follow the advice I have given myself so many times and really only post in threads that interest me.

 

[Mournblade94]

I agree. But the moment someone tries to use this data as a valid indicator wouldn't you think the natural response would be "hypocrisy"?

Again, if that was the case, then yes I would, but clearly this statistic is not indicative in any way. No more so than I think the amazon sales of 4e are indicative.

 

[Kask]

What exactly do you call your first post?

I was pointing out that WotC isn't doing as well as they'd like getting players to switch. Which is also the only reason to pull older ed PDFs...

Next time don't accuse me of something I didn't do. Got it?

 

[alleynbard]

Again, if that was the case, then yes I would, but clearly this statistic is not indicative in any way. No more so than I think the amazon sales of 4e are indicative.

Then you and I agree. I don't think any of that data is worth putting faith in, no matter what edition it applies to. Like you said, very much a point of interest and not much else.

 

[RefinedBean]

Slap fight!

White Wolf doesn't show up until #48 or so on Imaro's list. I figured they had a little more "oomph" than that.

Still, though, 'tis only Amazon.