Yeah, sure. I'll give Gav his equipment...
HA! Yeah, nice try though. Can't blame a guy for trying.
However, I do - ocassionally - reward players who aren't afraid to ask things that are out of the box. I've been mulling over this idea for a couple of days now and Barak's OOC question shows that I should run with it. So, here goes. Since you are 3rd level characters, I will grant each of you one or two major items that you had on your person that were stolen. They can be from the DMG only and have a cumulative value of 3,000 gp. (So ... one item of 3,000 gold or less -OR- two items that add up to 3,000 gp or less) You don't have to take this option of course, but it does provide you with a little leeway if you desire to have had something significant stolen - motivation for having your stuff returned ... so to speak.
And yes, I realize this doesn't benefit you in any way, because you are picking an item or two that was stolen ... but, well. C'est la vie, rieght?