Complete Warrior vs. Sword & Fist

[Mercule]

S&F has some good PrCs, some cool feats, and a couple of interesting weapons.

The "Role of the Fighter/Monk", the tactics, and the pages upon pages of (uninteresting) fortresses are pretty much useless. The tactics section is pretty thin and mostly along the level of "stick the pointy end into the other fellow... unless it looks like he's resistant (like a skeleton), then try a different weapon". About the only thing of value I found in that section was the formula to calculate average weapon damage (more complicated than you'd think).

I'd wait, if I were in your shoes.

 

[Hypersmurf]

Regarding errata - they've mostly been fixed in the second printing (which, from memory, is labelled "First Printing" ).

-Hyp.

 

[Olive]

I don't own any of the Wizard's class splat books. Actually I don't own class splat books from any company actually. So, I was thinking of picking up S&F, but I noticed that Complete Warrior will cover some of that material in it and be hardcover too.

Well, CW is suposed to be 75% new, so I suspect therte will be a lot of good stuff from S&F that won't make it into CW. And I like the splats, so I'd say pick it up if you've got the cash.