conducting a paternity test in D&D

atom crash

First Post
I need help in trying to figure out how someone in a D&D setting would conduct a paternity test. (Could this be the oddest request of the past few weeks?)

DM's note: Like most groups, my players are really good at overcoming challenges by fighting. So I like to give them non-standard challenges and plenty of roleplaying hooks to keep things interesting. Plus, they love opportunities to roleplay.

The PCs have been in a large city (10,000 residents) for nearly three months now. They've gotten famous (or infamous) for their exploits, as well as quite popular and of course rich, and everybody wants to hang out and be pals with the "heroes." We're about to finish one story arc and it has yet to be determined what comes next, so as an epilogue I plan to give each PC a reason to stay in town (i.e. be a hero and bask in the glow of popularity and wealth) as well as at least one reason to leave and find adventure elsewhere.

One of the PCs was in the habit of hiring escorts at the beginning of his adventurous career and it's about to come back to haunt him. We're talking about the party rogue, of course. He's a guy with a rather sleazy background -- drugs, women, booze, questionable ethics -- who has also been undergoing a journey of personal and moral growth throughout his career. He had his alignment magically altered from CN to LG, then he died and came back as CG. His moral compass has been dragged all over the place.

Enough background, now on to the point: in the near future, a young pregnant working girl will approach him with a claim that he's the father of her unborn child. She does this in a very public place so there's no way she can be later made to disappear without serious questions being raised. Is she blackmailing him? What does she want? Well, she wants him to take responsibility by marrying her and raising their child.

The timing's right, and she looks vaguely familiar, but the PC won't know for sure whether or not it's his child. Heck, I haven't even decided whether or not the child is his; I'll figure that out based on how he plays it. I'm thinking the PC will either "do the right thing" and take responsibility for the girl and her unborn child, he'll contest her claims that he's the father, or he'll comvince the other PCs it's time to get out of town.

So how would one go about attempting to prove in a D&D setting (roughly Victorian-age technology level and standard magic) that he is or isn't the father of the child? Without the use of DNA testing, how would a D&D paternity test be conducted? The PCs will of course have access to standard magic; they'll also have access to the local library run by the temple of the god of knowledge.

I've thought about a zone of truth spell to question the girl. The problem with that is she truly believes he's the father, regardless of whether or not he actually is.

Any ideas would be much appreciated.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

There are spells for this in third-party books. Valar Project's Book of Erotic Fantasy has the analyze ancestry spell, which shows a creature's ancestry back for ten generations. Likewise, Silverthorne Games's Minor Magicks has the spell blood tell, which gives genetic information about the creatures the spell is cast on, including if they're related to each other.

Both of these spells may not work on an unborn child (I'd say DM's discretion there), but if she's far enough along already, Minor Magicks also has the induce labor spell that you could cast on her to speed things up.

EDIT: Oh, and I suppose there's divination spells like contact other plane that you could use, but it seems like you'd have to use some pretty high-level ones for that.
 

how well off is the girl or her parents?

The only way to be completely sure of it would be a divination spell with a high probability of accuracy.

Zone of Truth is L2, runs at least 60gp, and the person cannot lie. If the girl really thinks the rogue is the father, that won't help.

Discern Lies is L4, runs at least 280gp, and reveals deliberate lies. If the girl really thinks the rogue is the father, that won't help.

Commune is L5, runs at least 450gp, and would get you what you need to know.
 

Hm... they could go about hiring a true oracle to look into the past (or future, to see what the child looks like)

Hackmaster has objects that can tell this sort of thing (but i suspect you're disinclined to allow to involving items from a game that involved thirteen kinds of fireballs.)
 

Easy. Kill the kid. And after you die and are being punished eternally for your sins, if one of them is "killing your own child" then you know it was yours. :uhoh:
 

Craft (alchemy) might be used to test blood types,but that says a lot about the sophistication of medical sciences in the setting.

The safest bet is like to come up with a new low level spell that could be cast by the priest of a fertility god. Or else come up with a new Domain power to associate with a Fertility Domain such as "Once per day learn the identity of the parents of a child."
 

That has always been a problem.

It was probably what drove men to marry women, and keep them shut up in a house. That way, they could at least pretend (saving face) that they were the fathers... Which was important in patriachial societies, where you have ownership of land (not really a problem in a hunter/gatherer society). I read on the BBC news site, that apparently some 5-7% of children were not related to the person they thought was their father...

Found one of the articles:
BBC News link

Chuck that 5% in over a few generations, and it strikes me that all this geneology craze seems like it may well be a good way to waste an incredible lot of time.

So those people pretending to be my ancestors in the 17th century (1600-1650, ten generations ago), only really have a 59.87% chance of actually being who they are say they are. Nevermind the poor sod who actually traced the ancestry back to 1080: 27.74% chance of actually correctly identifying that ancestor. Who can I sue?

Why do we seem to assume that people were less promiscuous in the old days, and that what was written in the old church books was true? I know from personal experience in small communities that there are all sorts of unspoken "truths" lying buried in people's closets, and all of the scandals die as the elder generation passes away. Unless of course you are someone really important, then it is just knowledge in the public domain.

Which is why ancient Egyptians traced line through the mother (it is the only thing you can be reasonably certain about, but that was falsified on occasion as well).

Back to the question at hand: it strikes me that this might well be left alone as one of the great mysteries/uncertainies facing people in life.
 

cmanos said:
...

Commune is L5, runs at least 450gp, and would get you what you need to know.

Contact Other Plane probably works, especially if your setting has an earth mother type goddess who could be asked.

Augury could let you know if claiming the kid would be helpful or harmful to you. Divination, cast shortly before the baby's due, might also provide useful information.

Legend Lore and Vision might be able to provide info as well.
 

I'd say the burdon of proof is on that woman. She must prove the child's parentage. Without evidence other than her word then the child's father should be assumed to be someone else.
 

If they have Victorian technology, then some cutting edge guy out there knows about the simple blood types (I think that was discovered in 1908 but with different attitudes towards research of the body and with magic helping things along it might well be discovered sooner). He would be able to tell who was not the father by simple blood type (For instance, if his and her blood types are O and the baby is type A, then he cannot be the father - a good twist would be to make her O and the child AB, which means it's not hers either), but unable to point 100% definately to a person, much like DNA testing today.
 

Remove ads

Top