Creating a demi-human race and society

Ok, we have a society where people need to congregate because of the Darkvision 60 foot limit problem, but where people need to stay apart because of the telepathic 'noise' they make (plus any verbal sounds.)
Real problem.

Let's give these people a behavioral modification. Let's create a trait for them that is distinctly exotic for humans, or downright non-human.
What mental trait should these people have?
What mental trait would be best, to allow them to live with the contradiction above (better to live together, better to live apart.)

After all, we want a society, not the Carolingian Empire descending into insane anarchy as everyone goes berserk telling everyone else to shut up!

One thing: don't make it a Telepathic Blocking Effect or the like. Let's do a behavioral change, not add a new power to these people.

Ok, anyone? What behavioral modification should it be?
 

log in or register to remove this ad

If you think a new minor power other than the obvious (the ability to block telepathic noise) is most suitable instead of a behavioral modification, then go ahead and suggest it.
I guess ... whichever is best, no?
 

So have we established that by 'always on' Telepathy means that you can pick up on every thought in a persons head and they can can pick up on the noise in yours
or that by always on one is always available to be contacted?

The description in the SRD says
A creature with this ability can communicate telepathically with any other creature within a certain range

that got me thinking about call signs. Perhaps directly sending a thought to someone is considered the hieght of rudeness and maybe even grounds for complaints of harrassment. Instead everyone has a unique call sign (personal identifier) which they are required to send first signally their desire to communicate and to which the receiving then signals to continue or declines. It provides a social check to unrelenting noise at least...
 

Let me try and clarify on the telepathic powers of the theoretical Franks:

It works very much like normal communication.
If you are close to someone, they can telepathically 'whisper' to you.
If you are far from someone, they must 'shout'. If you're too far away for normal verbal shouting, you're too far away for 'telepathic shouting.'
You can 'concentrate' on one person, to the exclusion of others, and thus talk to that person even in the midst of a telepathic 'uproar.' Just as we do this verbally all the time, so you can do it telepathically. The person you are focusing on, can return the concentration and communicate back telepathically.

You can talk to one person at a time easily. But talking to multiple people at once, is like trying to verbally talk to multiple people at once: difficult and annoying.
If multiple people try to telepathically 'talk' to you at once, it is (obviously) most annoying. Perhaps you can listen to two or more people at once, but if you can't do it with verbal communication, you can't do it with telepathy.

What blocks sound does *not* block telepathy.
Thus, being in a solid building is no protection from the telepathic 'uproar' going on in the marketplace outside.
Being outside the tavern is no protection from the telepathic 'uproar' going on inside the tavern (especially a barroom brawl ...)

You can telepathically 'put your fingers in your ears'
This lessens the noise, but it requires effort. After a time, it becomes annoying (just as holding your fingers in your ears would be annoying.) You can 'practice' at it, though, and thus lessen the annoyance, although doing it all day is still somewhat tiring.
'Putting your fingers in your ears' makes it difficult to talk to anyone, of course. All telepathic sound is dimmed, including that of the person you're trying to 'talk' to.

You can choose not to 'broadcast' thoughts. Or you can broadcast non-verbal 'noise' such as hissing, shouting, crying, yelling, and other things of this sort.
You can even telepathically 'sing' but to 'sing' well you must be proficient in singing.

You can choose to talk verbally, normally. If you do that, and simultaneously try to hold a telepathic conversation, then the result might be confusing as you are carrying on two conversations at once.

*If* verbal conversation, music, or other noise is occurring *and* telepathic conversation, singing, or other noise is occurring, the effects stack and it is harder yet to shut the racket out, or talk over it.
Thus, in a crowded tavern, where everyone is trying to - say - carry on two conversations at once, one verbal and one telepathic, while the waitress is telepathically asking for your order, while someone else at the table won't shut up and is loudly conversing verbally, it might be difficult for you to place that order.
When you shout or telepathically 'shout' to get over the din, you add to it ... and the uproar in the tavern gets louder yet (and louder and louder ...)

To telepathically talk with the waitress, you must be practiced at telepathically concentrating. If you want to verbally talk, you must be able to concentrate as normal people do to talk in crowded places.
If you 'put your fingers in your ears' it makes it harder to telepathically communicate with the waitress. If you don't, the background noise is much louder (sort of a no-win situation ...)

You can broadcast images. These images will be as clear or vague as your mental picture of them. You cannot do this *and* telepathically 'talk' simultaneously. Or, at least, not very well ... the double concentration required is going to lead to a confused, blurry picture and blurry telepathic 'speech.'
You can receive telepathic images, or 'put your hands over your eyes' to block them out. 'Putting your hands over your eyes' requires effort, on top of any other effort, but it does shut the images out.
If you choose to receive the 'image', and you are talking or sending images yourself, it is likely you won't remember the image since you weren't paying attention to it. On the other hand, if you are paying attention and not talking or sending pictures or verbally talking, then you are likely to remember the image very well.

If you are being forced to 'put your hands over your ears' to block out images, 'put your fingers in your ears' to block out telepathic sound, trying to hold a telepathic conversation in spite of this, and trying also to listen to verbal communications and respond in turn, you are probably going to end up irritated, agitated, angry, and finally quite exhausted.
 
Last edited:

Add in the confusion of 'conquered races' who cannot use telepathy or darkvision ...

How do the Franks handle this? What kind of social etiquette is observed?

Or is there a third option ... the Franks have a third power, a third ability besides darkvision and telepathy, and this third power allows them to live with each other?
Or is it merely that they behave in a non-human fashion to cope? A behavioral change?
 

Telepathy has huge social implications, depending on it's nature.

There would likely be times and places where it is considered appropriate to use telepathy, and times and places where only vocal speech is considered appropriate, and times and places where *only* telepathy is considered appropriate. Words spoken aloud might be considered 'for public consumption' while mental speech is 'private.' A town crier would stand in the square, reading off his proclamations, but in the royal court, silence reigns as a half-dozen courtiers are engaged in private side-conversations that cannot be eavesdropped upon. Inside the home, kids play, while their parents have a frank conversation 'over their heads.' The teacher speaks upon the subject of the day, knowing from long experience which students are focused upon her words, and which are focused entirely upon their private conversations with the objects of their affections.

Many of the features of the modern internet would be present. Just as the man on the laptop in the restaurant could be engaged in dirty chat with someone, so to could the 'absent-minded' young noblewoman be having a psychic tryst with that equally distracted-looking sweaty gardener (who is notably not her husband) over yonder.

Anonymity would also be a feature. In the real-world, many found the nerve to speak hateful or threatening words to Jews or Gypsies or homosexuals, but in a world where one can send a hateful *thought* to someone, and remain unseen, and have no one else 'witness' this threatening or harassing behavior, all sorts of 'bravery' will appear in the people who would otherwise have scowled but held their tongue. The despised minority will 'hear' threats and insults all day long, and not know which of the people glaring at him are the sources of these comments. Many of them may come from people that can see him (from a second story window, or across a crowded marketplace) but whom he cannot quickly locate to identify. And, as a member of a minority, it's not like he can run to a judge or guardsman, even if he did identify the source of the threat, as it's 'his word against theirs,' since there would be no witnesses to this sort of speech, and in this sort of 'he said, she said' situation, the despised minority always loses the case.

If line of sight and / or line of effect is not required, and a telepathic conversation can be held through walls, the use of 'speakers' may become commonplace among the wealthy. Going to meet the nobleman that has hired one's services, one would be led to a room with an attractive young man or woman who would greet you on behalf of Lord Whathisface. She would have a 'script' of what the Lord wants said to your group, and in the event where your line of conversation goes 'off-script,' she would close her eyes for a second, contact the Lord, clarify things, and then proceed 'speaking' for him. In noble courts, these speakers would be referred to as Seneschals, and speak 'with the voice of the king,' but wealthy merchants would be as likely to use such. Indeed, a wealthy young noble may not even directly meet her *suitors,* but instead speak to them through such a proxy, leaving a suitor in the awkward position of not even knowing what the woman he has 'spoken to' on several visits actually looks like, or, in a Cyrano de Bergerac fashion, end up falling in love with the speaker, instead of the woman she is speaking for!

Even if line of sight is required, the use of 'one way mirrors' or walls with see-through frescos or construction (such as those little walls that stand between a priest-confessor and his parishioner, obscuring things, but not blocking line of sight) would be an option. The king can see into the room, from who knows where, and his words can be heard by his Seneschal, who can then convey them to those who stand in his presence.

Depending on how easy it is to 'lie' using telepathy, it is possible that someone with severe ADHD, who finds it difficult to 'tune' his thoughts, might end up having the psychic version of Tourette's Syndrome, prone to blurting out whatever comes to mind as he attempts to telepathically 'speak.' Such people would be considered embarassments, and be socially ostracized and unlikely to engage in mental speech, because of their 'handicap.' On the other hand, in some situations, they may play the role of 'wise fool.' Knowing how difficult it is for such a person to engage in deception, a nobleman might prefer the 'plain speech' of his 'fool' to the oily twisted elocutions of his courtiers. Just as the 'wise fool' in primitive cultures found themselves the only person in a tribe able to actually tell the chieftan when his plan sucked, since they had no status to lose, the 'psychic tourette's' sufferer might be considered a 'truthspeaker,' and be a valued messenger among people who have reason to prefer a message that they can trust, rather than a pretty-sounding one.

The Duke may have to hold his temper listening to the young lad psychically digress about that enormous mole on his cheek and whether or not it was really true he had the last person to mention it drawn and quartered and how visible his wife's cleavage is in that dress, but at least he can be assured that the young man isn't lying to him when he says that the Baron wants to arrange a private meeting to discuss bumping off that annoying Count to the north and splitting up his territory by having his kids marry their own at crossbow-point before the King hears about it.

Telepathy also has potential as an interrogation tool. Even if limited to mind-speaking, and not actual mind-probing, a prisoner could be subjected to constant telepathic 'noise' during his confinement, left unable to sleep or concentrate until, after several days, he is a babbling nervous wreck, and a professional can be brought in to coax useful intelligence from his ramblings. Presumably mental speech is as tiring as verbal speech, so the guards can't just mentally sing 'Henry the Eighth, I am' or 'This is the song that never ends' for eight hours straight, but smaller shifts would be quite likely. Every hour another pair of guards show up for a single hour shift, and commence singing bawdy tunes to the prisoner, or reciting documents detailing the prisoners crimes and the archival records of what happened to the last prisoner executed for said crime...

"After an hour in the Spanish chair, Malvolio's feet were swollen and red, and he had stopped producing tears, although sobs still wracked his body, betimes. The skin had cracked and the juices sizzled as their crossed his flesh. He had entered a state of constant shuddering, as if his body was falling to pieces within, and the brazier was removed, and his feet plunged into a bucket of iced water, whereupon great convulsions racked his body, so severe that he broke one of the arms from his chair! He had ceased screaming some time before, but again a great cry of anguish tore from his throat and the flesh peeled away from his feet in clumps, forming a loathsome stew. Finally he shuddered once and fell dead shock to the body and perhaps even mortal terror. Justice was done, and I removed myself from the chamber, sickened by the smell of meat and the rumbling it incited within my traitorous belly."

After three days of constant mental haranguing, the prisoner would be delerious and babbling, easy prey for a professional interrogator, with no need for actual physical abuse, and no fear that an overzealous guard will 'accidentally' kill him and thus deprive the authorities of any information that they need from him.
 

If this telepathy isn't sudden, I don't see why they'd have a problem with it at all. Like with any persistent "sound", it would likely fade into a "background noise" for everyone involved. I could imagine something like that even being comforting in a way; a sound that's been with you since you were a baby, letting you know that you're not alone.

So rather than isolate themselves, I could see the Franks gaining an almost monophobic tendency and clustering around in groups of their own kind simply because other races are so unsettling to be around (they might not know why).

Conversely, the lack of telepathy might also make non-Frankish servants prized by the nobility since they can keep what they overhear "quiet".
 

Fascinating!

Let's assume that one can, as with verbal conversation, choose to 'not listen' to a telepathic message (just as one might deliberately ignore someone rudely shouting verbally ... they'll still hear the annoying sound, but not understand it as they weren't listening.)

Let's make a big assumption: *Mirrors* block telepathy.

A True Mirror - a mirror of silvered glass - completely blocks telepathy, one-way.

A shiny, polished metal plate (a metal mirror) blocks it completely, both ways.
Water acts to shut it out. The more water, the more it shuts it out until it shuts it out totally (since water is partially reflective.)
Lumps of metal that would be reflective if shaped and polished cut it down partially. The more metal, the more it dims it.
Ordinary glass partially shuts it out. It depends on how reflective the glass is, and how thick it is. To completely shut it out, would require either a lot of glass or highly reflective glass.

Thus, lead wouldn't be very useful, for it reflects poorly. Silver would work well. Shiny silica would also work. Even water poured into walls would help.

No light is needed. The presence of light is irrelevant. Only how well the object *reflects* or could (if shaped) reflect light is relevant.

EDIT: Lying with telepathy would be as easy, in this case, as lying normally. False images could be envisoned and sent to as lies, as well.
 

Given the problems with it, telepathy now seems like a less-used secondary form of communication (at least, when in town). Only useful for when you need to talk to everyone regardless of intervening barriers. (like calling for help, or spreading important public announcements from the king.)

Also, worse reception during rain.
 

Ok, let's transfer these guys over to a setting. Pick one of your favorites or homebrew, and a place therein. :)

Now, give them a base alignment - the base alignment of the race (ala the drow are evil, but your PC need not be so.)
Don't give them True Neutral alignment. Anything else is ok.
Describe how their alignment affects their society and personal lives. Describe how it affects their mentality.

Then, give them a religion. Are they monotheistic? (worshipping only Torm, or Heironeous, or Paladine ... or Bane, or Hextor, or Takhisis?) Are they polytheistic? Combination? Internal strife over religion?
What about the religions of the conquered (human) peoples? What are these? Are they suppressed? Allowed?

And what name shall we call these people? Carolinians? Franks? Something else?

Remember that these people, based on your posts, have:

- Darkvision 60 feet as per the core rules.
- Telepathy. It works much like speech and normal sound, and can be used in conjunction with normal speech and soundmaking. It is blocked by objects that would reflect images like a mirror would: the more substance and the more reflective, the more it blocks the telepathy (just as a wall of thicker and denser wood would block sound.) Visual images can be sent, if the person does nothing else simultaneously.
- As an Extraordinary Power, these people are accustomed to loud noise and telepathic noise, and indeed find it aestetic. Their ears are not damaged by loud noise as quickly or easily as human ears. And they are still as comfortable as humans in silent conditions as well.

- They have a homebrew, extremely complicated set of rules and etiquette regarding the 60 Foot Limit (the 60 foot limit of their darkvision.)
- They tend to congregate in groups, with protective measures set beyond the 60 Foot Limit.
- Their shops stay open day and night.
- Their other establishments are generally open day and night.
- Some of their peasants work during the day, and others work at night.
- Trade, commerce, military drills, and court activities all occur day and night.
- Mining plays a larger role in their society, since it requires no light sources and is thus easier for them.
 

Remove ads

Top