D&D 5E D&D Magic the Gathering alternate magic system

[CubicsRube]

I replied the way I did BECAUSE you were NOT asking for opinions. You were asking people to do the work for you.

So, that is a nice redirection of attention and trying to blame me for it, but I'm not buying it.

If you want opinions, state it. If you want work done, generally the best thing to do is start out by generating work of your own and sharing it... or asking if there's products out there that do what you want, which I believe the Spheres series does.

No I didn't ask for others to do the work for me. This is to share ideas for people that want to.

And since you're being an A-hole you can take a report and a block.

 

[Aelryinth]

No I didn't ask for others to do the work for me. This is to share ideas for people that want to.

And since you're being an A-hole you can take a report and a block.

Wow, nice passive aggressive when I can look right at your first post and see you are NOT asking for opinions.
Right back at you for swearing and name-calling.

I suggest you restart the thread posting how you changed the game and based off that inquire if anyone else would like to share their changes too.

 

[aco175]

I choose you, Pikachu, wait... That is too much work.

 

[Laurefindel]

My solution was to leave spellcaster classes as they are but disconnect them from their spell lists. Then I reworked all spells into five spell lists, one for each colour.

 

[Aelryinth]

I choose you, Pikachu, wait... That is too much work.

If that's directed at the Summoning school, that's pretty much why I never bothered Summoning stuff

 

[Aelryinth]

My solution was to leave spellcaster classes as they are but disconnect them from their spell lists. Then I reworked all spells into five spell lists, one for each colour.

Did you just chop up the lists a bit, or rework them entirely? And did you keep a universal school?
Also, were there 'gold' spells of multiple colors?

 

[CubicsRube]

My solution was to leave spellcaster classes as they are but disconnect them from their spell lists. Then I reworked all spells into five spell lists, one for each colour.

Did you produce something on this?

I was thinking to make a "planeswalker" class where you have to choose 1 colour and that determines your list.

I'm uncertain if I would have a setting with only planeswalkers, or combine with other classes (particularly the mundanes), or if I'd allow planeswalkers to learn multiple colours of spells (and how that would work)

I would be tempted to have a planeswalker only campaign with single colour specialists however.

 

[CubicsRube]

I choose you, Pikachu, wait... That is too much work.

Yes, more of a muse product than anything serious.

Although if I find myself with an abundance source of energy and time, I might put together some spell lists and post them here for critique.

 

[Laurefindel]

Did you just chop up the lists a bit, or rework them entirely? And did you keep a universal school?
Also, were there 'gold' spells of multiple colors?

I reworked the lists entirely, but didn't make any gold or colorless spells.

Did you produce something on this?

I was thinking to make a "planeswalker" class where you have to choose 1 colour and that determines your list.

I still have them somewhere. At that time the only spells outside the PHB were from the Elemental Companion, so the lists don't comprise spells from Xanathar or Tasha.

Making one planeswalker class seams more manageable than five new ones (or fifteen if you count double-colour decks)

 

[CubicsRube]

I guess another question is if anyone would want to be a mundane character when you could be a planeswalker