That last guy you linked did his review right after he did his unboxing review. He hadn't even read the book yet. So it's really a playtest review. He also ordered the limited set, and then spends time complaining that it came with "stuff" that only the limited set came with.
- He's the guy who went into McDonalds, saw a burger meal and a happy meal, stated that he hated meals that came with toys, and the bought the happy meal - then wrote a review slamming it for having a toy... when the 'burger meal' was a regular meal and $100 cheaper.
The reality is everyone doesn't like the game. Not the end of the world 
