I think as with most people who have posted here it's more about the thanks than actual gifts for me.QUOTE]
Don't get me wrong; they always say thanks for the games and the messageboard is nearly always filled with comments and compliments, both for me and the other players. The table and the tickets were a grand gesture of thanks that I never in a million years expected.
We've had cookouts before games where everyone brings something to burn on the grill (the biggest one saw me DM for 16 players once...oy). Everyone brings snacks and drinks, some buy materials for the group as a whole. One of my players does demos for a large gaming shop, so he gets books and such at a big discount for all of us.
I once got into a big argument with a friend and former campaigner (we live too far apart to game now) where he believed I should charge an admission to my games because he believed they were that good. I told him he was out of his mind and I'd never do that. I look at DMing as an art form, and it's something I do out of love of the game, not for pay. The fact they did this without my knowledge really showed me the work I've put into our home brew campaigns was appreciated, and that they'd rather game with me than any other DM. Truly, more than any material prize, that is the greatest reward.