Does Anybody Own (Bastion) Airships & (Goodman) The Aerial Adventure Guide?

[Angel Tarragon]

I will be purchasing Bastion Press's Airships and Goodman Games Aerial Adventure Guide sometime this week. I pose a question is there any gamer(s) out there that own these two products? If so how well do the two books intermesh? Part of my world is the Skyrealms and I need something for transportation, I figure I can cover all ends of the spectrum by obtaining both books. Anyone have anything to say about these books? Comments or reviews?

 

[Angel Tarragon]

bump.

 

[C. Baize]

I only own one of them.

And it's not very good in my opinion.
Great idea.... mediocre execution.

 

[Psion]

As you might guess by the respective topics of the books, Airships take on vehicles is rather more in-depth, and provides you with more options. Since it's only one of many topics in AAG, their take on Airships is a little more basic.

In brief, but there you go. I have both of them reviewed on the reviews page.

 

[Teflon Billy]

I own them both and like them both just fine. Bastion's Airships was--to my shocked delight--one of my favorite products that year (Shocked because I had not given Airships any thought whatsover in my low-magic campigning). It's a very interesting read, and filled with useable material.

Aerial Adventure Guide is a substantially different product than Airships in that it is much more "setting" than actual Airships (the rules are in there, just not as elaborate or, in my opinion, as flavorful as in the much more specialized Airships).

I think they are both fine products, and will liley serve you well.