Dynamic Excel "Wiesbaden Charactersheet"

[dulac50]

Question and possible bug

When you enter a weapon on the attacks page that is an implement for a swordmage and that weapon is a magic weapon with an extra bonus on a critical, does the bonus damage for the critical apply for spell attacks with keywords including implement and not weapon?

The XP Version is giving the critical damage from swordburst and flame cyclone as XX + 1d6 where the "1d6" is the bonus from a critical with the weapon.

I am not sure if this is correct. If it is not, then this is another bug. If it is correct, then no problem.

 

[dulac50]

Bug with Critical damage included when a weapon is used as an implement

I have given this some thought and my conclusion is that the critical damage from a melee weapon which is used as an implement is not appropriate when a spell with a burst, blast or range deals damage and a critical has been rolled. Therefore, this is definitely an error or a bug in the character sheet.

 

[Mithreinmaethor]

I have given this some thought and my conclusion is that the critical damage from a melee weapon which is used as an implement is not appropriate when a spell with a burst, blast or range deals damage and a critical has been rolled. Therefore, this is definitely an error or a bug in the character sheet.

Even staves, wands and orbs add this critical damage. There is no reason a weapon used as an implement should not.

 

[xone01]

Even staves, wands and orbs add this critical damage. There is no reason a weapon used as an implement should not.

i agree, the description of magical staffs (240 & 241 of the PHB) says that they apply to both melee attacks and powers that use the staff as an implement. by that logic, a longsword used as an implement should apply all the benefits that it would get on a melee attack (happy day, swordmagi!)

 

[elandy]

I have given this some thought and my conclusion is that the critical damage from a melee weapon which is used as an implement is not appropriate when a spell with a burst, blast or range deals damage and a critical has been rolled. Therefore, this is definitely an error or a bug in the character sheet.

No, it's working ok.
From the FAQ:

17. When you are using a magic weapon as an implement, like a Holy Avenger or a Pact Dagger, what benefits do you get from the weapon?
You gain any bonuses listed under Enhancement, Critical and Property.

 

[dulac50]

Thanks for setting me right guys.

 

[dulac50]

Bug on Resistances for Genasi

The Charsheet I shows Resistance 5 Fire, 5 Lightning, 5 Cold when the character is a genasi firesoul. It should only be 5 Fire.

If you choose Akanul as a home region which confers Resistance 2 cold, fire and thunder, the Charsheet I shows resistance 7 Fire (correct), 5 Lightning (incorrect), 2 Thunder (correct), 7 Cold (incorrect).

 

[nytecoldawn]

Skill Section on Charsheet 1

You can not edit the fields for item bonuses or Misc bonuses like you were able to in past editions. I am using wiesbaden_charsheet_v1_16_Full.xls character sheet. Seems to affect the wiesbaden_charsheet_v1_16.xls as well.

Great sheet over all guys.

--- edit. Nevermind, I missed the section on the extra bonuses tab.

 

[koesherbacon]

wiesbaden_charsheet_v1_16.xls as well.

I can't seem to find this 1.16 version... Can you point me in the right direction to download the excel files?

Thanks!

 

[Shadowsong666]

I can't seem to find this 1.16 version... Can you point me in the right direction to download the excel files?

Thanks!

Post #188 right in this thread.