Oiginally posted by jdavis
Perhaps they would have to also swear a much more strict oath or several oaths even (maybe even a binding magical one). I am very much behind the fact that a Ranger who breaks his oaths to the town and Lady Kelvin in any way would face execution. The Silk Fish guilds would also have a vested intrest in the Rangers, as one of their primary task is to patrol for poachers and smugglers around the lake. They would have to be hand picked and 100% reliable (they could make a fortune if they turned their back to certain silk fish smuggling operations). Bringing them out of the military organization and introducing them as a self contained group would allow them a lot of power and leeway outside the wall, this would have to be countered to insure they are 100% loyal. They would also more than likely work as individuals or as small groups, which increases the risk of a rogue ranger even more.