• COMING SOON! -- Level Up: Advanced 5th Edition! Level up your 5E game! The standalone advanced 5E tabletop RPG adds depth and diversity to the game you love!
log in or register to remove this ad

 

Exploring Candlekeep Mysteries: An In-depth Review

Candlekeep Mysteries is an absolute gift for DMs. D&D 5th Edition adventure books have been either one big adventure like Icewind Dale: Rime of the Frostmaiden and Curse of Strahd (original or Revamped) or collections of short adventures like Ghosts of Saltmarsh. Candlekeep Mysteries would be categorized with the latter, but it’s so much more.
dnd_cm_cover.png

Meet Candlekeep​

Candlekeep is a citadel on the Sword Coast that houses the largest library and collection of knowledge in all of Faerun. To enter Candlekeep one must donate a book or scroll it doesn't already possess.

At the simplest, most direct level Candlekeep Mysteries is a book about books—and a book of books. Each of the 17 adventures is tied to and sparked by a book within the library, complete with an image and text description of the book.

dnd_cm_altcover.png

A Library of Possibilities​

DMs can raid Candlekeep Mysteries over and over again for ideas, NPCs, and maps that can be repurposed. The adventures can be run as is, expanded to turn into a longer campaign, or modified and inserted into existing campaigns. Candlekeep Mysteries contains a wealth of inspiration that could make it the most useful official D&D book for DMs after the core trinity.

None of that flexibility is by accident. A section called Dissecting the Adventures gives several examples of how the adventure for 16th-level characters, Xanthoria, could be repurposed. Since that one relates to the demon princes Juiblex and Zuggtmoy, it could also easily be changed to fit with or be an epilogue to Rage of Demons, as just one example.

If you're running a campaign that isn't set in Forgotten Realms, Candlekeep Mysteries can still work for you. For Eberron campaigns just switch it to the Library of Korranberg. Do you still play Greyhawk? Make it the Great Library in the City of Greyhawk. Is Exandria you could use either Soltryce Academy in Wildemount or the Cobalt Reserve in Tal'dorei instead, or any great enclave of knowledge and books in your homebrew.

Candlekeep Mysteries can also be set in any time period you wish. The book states who fills key roles in DR 1492, but you can substitute others appropriate for the time period you choose. So if you're still playing 3.5 or 4th edition and use the earlier time period you can just convert the adventures.

If you're well-versed in Forgotten Realm lore and the prior adventures you'll also find fun Easter eggs in Candlekeep Mysteries. For example, a book called Storm King's Thunder can be found inside the library.

Jeremy Crawford and other D&D staff talk regularly about how shifting sensibilities are going to play out in future adventures. Candlekeep Mysteries provides some insight to these directions with how the Vistani are depicted in Book of the Raven, which includes Tale of Vistani Kindness.


IMG_6995.jpg

Expansive Opportunities​

Taken as a whole, the adventures are also expansive, ranging from being solely set in Candlekeep to ones that take the players to places like Waterdeep, Baldur's Gate, and Anauroch, plus demiplanes. Since WotC occasionally hints at what is to come, maybe the latter is a sign we'll finally get Planescape sometime soon? That may just be my own wishful thinking.

Other adventures include species of good alignment that have previously been depicted as evil or, in one case, a lesser form of evil than their historic chaotic evil alignment. Similarly, the book notes that if an NPC's gender identity or alignment is not explicitly stated, the DM can determine it as they see fit. These changes add more flexibility and potential plot twists to a story because players can't make assumptions before interacting with them.

As the book's title implies, the adventures center around mysteries and investigation. Plenty of action is also included, such as opportunities to fight a dracolich and a lichen lich, to name two serious challenges, but some can be resolved without violence.

Before delving into the adventures, the book gives an overview of how Candlekeep operates, its rules, and the magic that protects it. Avowed are the main staff who assist visitors with research. Stat blocks are provided for Sages and Master Sage. Eight Avowed guides are provided in a random chart in addition to ones met in specific adventures.

Similarly the eight Great Readers in DR 1492 who make up the council get a brief description. Miirym, the sentinel wyrm, gets a full stat block, as benefits a CR 22 guardian. A large, detachable map of Candlekeep is also included in the book.

The art is extremely cohesive and the images of the books would fit seamlessly next to the magic item art in the Dungeon Master's Guide. The mainstream cover by Clint Cearley sets the mood by showing a scene of adventurers studying a book, but my favorite is the special edition. Simen Meyer's gold-embossed cover looks like a book that might be found in Candlekeep.

IMG_6997.jpg

But What About The Adventures?​

If you're a player, stop here. Spoilers ahead so only DMs should proceed.

The first tale is The Joy of Extradimensional Spaces, a first-level adventure. As the title indicates, the players end up in an extradimensional space to find a missing sage, but then have to figure out how to leave themselves. First-level adventures can be difficult to balance a viable challenge with the players' limited abilities and hit points. This one includes a puzzle for them to figure out in addition to facing challenges like a swarm of animated books. This adventure can easily be expanded to include more about the problem that requires the missing sage. The map for Fistandia's mansion by Dyson Logos is also handy for any DM whose group uses Mordenkainen's Magnificent Mansion.

The second-level adventure Mazfroth's Mighty Digressions features a book that is actually a monster. Figuring out how that came to be—the titular book is rare but well-known—takes the players to the markets of Baldur's Gate and a group of werejackels who are trying to make the money to resurrect their leader, a kind lamia more interested in books than torture who was killed by adventurers on sight. This adventure provides options for resolving the case with and without violence.

Book of the Raven is a third-level adventure that provides a glimmer of the revised version of the Vistani as well as a shadow crossing while players visit a chalet that houses a secret society. The wereraven stat block in this adventure is the same as that from Curse of Strahd.

Fourth-level adventure A Deep and Creeping Darkness lives up to its name. The players are hired to find out what happened to the town of Vermilion, which was abandoned shortly after an explosion in its platinum mine because survivors began disappear.

Even though that adventure is firmly horror, the next adventure, also for 4th-level players, Shemshime's Bedtime Rhyme might tap player fear even more due to the real-world events of the past year. The tome involved is more of a cross between a pop-up book and a music box, but it conveys a musical curse that is highly contagious, forcing the players to be quarantined in Candlekeep's Firefly Cellar to contain its effects. As the curse continues, foul events occur until the players discover a way to end it.

The Price of Beauty, a 5th-level adventure, takes the players to the Temple of the Restful Lily. While dedicated to Sune, the temple and bath house near Silverymoon has been taken over by disguised green hags who offer deals that pervert the person's desires.

The 6th-level adventure Book of Cylinders features a tale that was designated as something yet to come, and that time seems to be now. The “book” contains cylinders that must be rolled over clay to reveal its story told through symbols. Prodded by the disappearance of crab harvests used to feed residents of Candlekeep, players will discover a tribe of grippli displaced from their fishing village and caught between groups of good and evil yuan-ti.

Sarah of Yellowcrest Manor, a 7th-level adventure, is a book haunted by a girl murdered along with several others to gain power from a Great Old One. The remains of the family murdered is powering further evil as the murder builds a cult. He is also planning a vile ritual that will require many more deaths—unless the players can figure out what really happened, stop the cult, lay the family to rest, and deliver justice to the murderer.

Lore of Lurue, for 8th-level characters, is a storybook adventure that was written by the first High Mage of Silverymoon at the request of a lesser deity. It pulls players into a tale of the god Malar attempting to corrupt the unicorn avatar of Lurue, long before Silverymoon was founded in the same area.

Kandlekeep Dekonstruktion, a 9th-level adventure, is change of pace with a wild premise. The Candlekeep tower known as “Barn Door” holds a secret—in its depths is an ancient mechanism that could launch the tower into space if the cult working to do that succeeds. Touches like this keep making me feel like WotC is teasing us with Spelljammer hints.

Tenth-level adventure Zikran's Zephyrean Tome has the djinn Gazre-Azam bound to a book. The djinn offers the players a wish in exchange for freeing him from the binding spells of a water genasi mage. Zikran has made an elemental cannon and is working to turn a cloud giant keep into a floating fortress for his evil schemes.

The Curious Tale of Wisteria Vale, a 11th-level adventure, appears to be a fictional play about a demiplane created by the Harpers to imprison a bard who has been corrupted. The players can try to finish the tale by finding and curing the bard but the players will also have to deal with a beholder with its own agenda.

Twelfth-level adventure The Book of Inner Alchemy takes the players to the far east to find pages stolen from the titular book. The evil Order of Immortal Lotus wish to create Gloves of Soul Catching. Doing so requires sacrificing a being of pure heart, a being of great intellect, and a being of strong body, with the souls of all three utterly destroyed.

The Canopic Being is a 13th-level adventure that takes the characters to Tashluta on the Chultan peninsula. If your players have ever experienced DMs who take away player autonomy you might want to prepare them for a surprise early in this adventure—the players' names are listed in the book as “The Bestowed—willing sacrifices.: The process involves a mummy lord placing one of their organs into the body of a living person instead of a canopic jar, turning the person into their servant. This hasn't actually been done yet to the characters—an oracle has seen that they can thwart the mummy lord Valin so their names were included to draw them in. Still, if your players have had bad experiences in the past, you might want to give them some sort of warning so the players don't assume their characters are being abused.

Fourteenth-level adventure The Scrivener's Tale pits characters against an evil fey but also might press the players' pandemic buttons. The characters are infected by the scrivener's mark, which can only be removed by a wish or defeating the Princess of Shadow Glass.

Like Tomb of Annihilation, The Scrivener's Tale involves a timetable for accelerating the mark, which can lead to total petrification if the character isn't killed through other aspects of the mark, such as becoming brittle as glass. The adventure gives advice on slowing down the clock if, say, the characters travel to Baldur's Gate by land instead of teleportation. Adventures with a death clock mechanic are tricky to pace properly to keep up the tension without accelerating too soon so while I like the adventure overall, I'm not fond of that aspect.

Alkazaar’s Appendix, a 15th-level adventure, takes the characters to Anauroch to unite a lost golem with its master, who possesses one of the Nether Scrolls, which describe how the weave of magic works. The two were separated when a black dragon tried to seize the scroll. After failing, the dragon became a dracolich to wait out the spell preserving the mage so you have to reunite the golem and its master while thwarting the dracolich so the mage can take the scroll to Elysium.

The final adventure, Xanthoria, involves a deadly fungal infection that is destroying crops and turning people into zombie-like creatures. The title comes from the name of a druid who was corrupted by demon madness, and triggered the infestation, which won't end so long as she is lives. The influence of Zuggtmoy turned the druid into a lichen lich with a sprite who functions as a living phylactery. If the DM plays Thunderwings properly, the resolution of Xanthoria could break the players' hearts.


IMG_7048.jpg

Should You Buy It?​

While I generally prefer a single adventure instead of anthologies, I love Candlekeep Mysteries. While some of the adventures are more to my taste than others, overall I like the variety and mix of challenges. While they involve plenty of action, mindless combat isn't the point, though players can always find a way to do that.

More importantly, the D&D team did a great job making Candlekeep Mysteries a resource DMs can use over and over. Candlekeep is set up well to be a recurring setting for your campaign, whether that's Forgotten Realms or homebrew. I also plan to raid the book for NPCs and maps.

Having such a range of levels combined with how they're written makes it easy to slip these adventures into an existing campaign. Like one a lot? It can easily be expanded to become a larger campaign.

For the flexibility, creativity, and overall execution, Candlekeep Mysteries is a winner and, I suspect, will be a bestseller.

 
Last edited by a moderator:

log in or register to remove this ad

Beth Rimmels

Beth Rimmels


log in or register to remove this ad



jeremypowell

Adventurer
Avernus should be 1494, as that 1492 is probably a typo, since it does not match up to the actual lore in the book of a particular 50-year event.
Should be, yes—but according to the book’s page on the FR Fandom site, it has been officially set as 1492 by WotC, and indeed the BG3 video game (whose plot takes up where Descent into Avernus leaves off) begins later in 1492. So the book’s own internal evidence doesn’t jibe with the place it has to occupy in the timeline.

I mean, this sort of thing happened back in 2e too, but back then there were dozens of additions to the canon each year. Nowadays there are two or three FR products a year; you wouldn’t think it’d be that tough to keep the dates straight on them.
 



Should be, yes—but according to the book’s page on the FR Fandom site, it has been officially set as 1492 by WotC, and indeed the BG3 video game (whose plot takes up where Descent into Avernus leaves off) begins later in 1492. So the book’s own internal evidence doesn’t jibe with the place it has to occupy in the timeline.

I mean, this sort of thing happened back in 2e too, but back then there were dozens of additions to the canon each year. Nowadays there are two or three FR products a year; you wouldn’t think it’d be that tough to keep the dates straight on them.
Especially since wasn't that what they hired Sean K Reynolds specifically for?
 


jayoungr

Legend
I’m so sad that the maps aren’t battlemap worthy. I mean 😪 I mean I get that Dyson Logos maps have their fans but it reduces the value of the book immeasurably without quality maps for online play. With all WOCs resources and the great artists available it’s deeply disappointing.
Ah, that is disappointing. Nothing against Dyson Logos--those maps are super-clear on the page, which is great--but I really miss Mike Schley. I'm starting to wonder what happened between him and WotC that they don't work together anymore.

I am equal parts curious and apprehensive to see how shifting sensibilities have affected the rebranding of the Vistani. Can you let us know what this looks like?
I wouldn't worry too much about it. The season 4 AL adventures already had the PCs dealing with non-evil Vistani in a friendly way, and that was years before the formal "rebranding."
 

jeremypowell

Adventurer
I really miss Mike Schley. I'm starting to wonder what happened between him and WotC that they don't work together anymore.
I don't think anything happened to him, and I would expect to continue to see his work in future products.

There's never been a period in which only he illustrated maps for WotC (they've always used other cartographers alongside him, often even within a single book). And his maps are prevalent in Rime of the Frostmaiden, which until Candlekeep Mysteries was still the most recent book with maps in it. So unless I've missed some news, they're still working together; he just doesn't do all the maps, and never has.
 


jeremypowell

Adventurer
Are all the Rime maps reprints of old maps?

Edit: Schley did maps of Icewind Dale for Legacy of the Crystal Shard (2013), but the eleven maps in Rime are different from those. His website says they were "created for" Rime. I'm pretty sure they're new.
 

Mercurius

Legend
With all the Dyson Logos bashing, I'll go on record as saying that I really like his maps. They are conducive to a theater-of-mind style play and help facilitate an approach of shared imagination.

I personally dislike maps that look like stills from a video game. I find that they tend to anchor the focus on the map itself rather than the shared imagination.

To each their own, though. Call me old school, I guess.
 

TheSword

Legend
With all the Dyson Logos bashing, I'll go on record as saying that I really like his maps. They are conducive to a theater-of-mind style play and help facilitate an approach of shared imagination.

I personally dislike maps that look like stills from a video game. I find that they tend to anchor the focus on the map itself rather than the shared imagination.

To each their own, though. Call me old school, I guess.
I think you have said it well. Dyson Logos maps are perfect for theatre of the mind, where people are looking for simplicity and clarity. They don’t want clutter over the map obscuring everything.

I just think that with the quantity of battlemap style play - particularly online they should cater with appropriate battlemaps too.

I’d actually be fine with a separate map pack. I’ve bought a few of those made by 3pp on DMGuild but they’re a mixed bag to be honest.

Ive seen that Heroic Maps - they are excellent quality - has started working through Dragon Heist Maps so fingers crossed.
 


Are all the Rime maps reprints of old maps?

Edit: Schley did maps of Icewind Dale for Legacy of the Crystal Shard (2013), but the eleven maps in Rime are different from those. His website says they were "created for" Rime. I'm pretty sure they're new.
I believe the town maps are redrawn, but following the earlier cartography.
I personally dislike maps that look like stills from a video game. I find that they tend to anchor the focus on the map itself rather than the shared imagination.
It depends on what you want to do with them. For a tabletop game simple clear maps are best. But for play online then colourful maps with lots of detail are best.
 

jeremypowell

Adventurer
[Re: Dyson's maps] IIt depends on what you want to do with them. For a tabletop game simple clear maps are best. But for play online then colourful maps with lots of detail are best.
Agreed. I'm disappointed they're using Dyson Logos, but I'm hardly a basher; as I said above, DL's maps are "fantastic" in miniature, on the page, in the books. I've never used printed-out versions for live play, but maybe they do work great there too. The problem is they look really, really bad in online play, where you usually have to zoom in far enough that work in DL's style just starts to looks crude, even though it isn't. Schley's maps look great for all purposes, so I prefer them.
 

trs31

Explorer
Chris Perkins wrote that adventure, which starts with the story contained in the Book of Ravens, detailing how the unnamed author traveled with the Vistani for a time, and they showed great kindness while the writer was injured. It includes Vistani lore about them being planar travelers who can traverse shadow crossings. The lore also describes the Vistani as people who display their wealth openly because they view it as a blessing and that they put great value on hospitality.
Well that doesn't sound too different from what we have now. Thanks.
 

trs31

Explorer
Ah, that is disappointing. Nothing against Dyson Logos--those maps are super-clear on the page, which is great--but I really miss Mike Schley. I'm starting to wonder what happened between him and WotC that they don't work together anymore.


I wouldn't worry too much about it. The season 4 AL adventures already had the PCs dealing with non-evil Vistani in a friendly way, and that was years before the formal "rebranding."
I agree that the Vistani haven't been portrayed as just evil for a long time and I think that's a good thing. I like the similarities to Romani culture though and I think as long as the positive elements of that are focused on and they aren't portrayed as a negative stereotype then there isn't any need to change them too much.
 

MNblockhead

A Title Much Cooler Than Anything on the Old Site
regarding the maps, I'm a fan of both Schley and Dyson. I think WotC is leaving money on the table by not selling separate battlemap images. When I ran Curse of Strahd, I bough Schley's map pack, so I could have high-res, properly scaled maps. The images should could be included with the VTT versions as an extra perk but should also be available as image files. Both Kobold Press and Frog God Games do this and it is so DM friendly that while I've bought some of the WotC adventures after Curse of Strahd, I've not actually run any.
 

Visit Our Sponsor

Latest threads

Level Up!

An Advertisement

Advertisement4

Top