Feminously Gendered Feline Hivemind Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
No, I've seen it, but I'm not sure what you're talking about. Anakin is hardly a protagonist, and you don't see him slaughtering children or anything. You see him killing two people in a video, but that's about it. Obiwan and Yoda don't kill innocents, that I recall. Mace doesn't kill innocents. What are you referring to?
 

log in or register to remove this ad

Jdvn1 said:
No, I've seen it, but I'm not sure what you're talking about. Anakin is hardly a protagonist, and you don't see him slaughtering children or anything. You see him killing two people in a video, but that's about it. Obiwan and Yoda don't kill innocents, that I recall. Mace doesn't kill innocents. What are you referring to?
Anakin is most certainly the protagonist...he's the anti-hero of the movie, just as Macbeth and Medea are the protagonists of their works. And just because you don't see him chop up the kids doesn't make it any less disturbing when he pulls the 'sabre on them.
 


Rystil Arden said:
Anakin is most certainly the protagonist...he's the anti-hero of the movie, just as Macbeth and Medea are the protagonists of their works. And just because you don't see him chop up the kids doesn't make it any less disturbing when he pulls the 'sabre on them.
When he tries to kill Obiwan, I'd take awa 'protagonist' status from him. When he turns on everyone, same thing.

And you said:
I can see how you might not want your kiddies watching ... the slaughter of innocents by the protagonist.
I only mention it because your kiddies wouldn't be watching the slaughter. Like when Bambi's mother is killed, you don't see anything too gruesome.
 

Steve Jung said:
Wasn't there dialogue saying that Anakin killed younglings?
Yeah. The Star Wars gurus on the threads that pertain to that mention the 'younglings' is a term for Jedi-in-training, not necessarily children or kids of a certain age.
 

Steve Jung said:
Wasn't there dialogue saying that Anakin killed younglings?
He did kill the children offscreen. He drew a lightsabre on them and then when Obi-Wan and Yoda came in, they checked the children's corpses and saw that they had been slaughtered via lightsabre, then they found the perpetrator to be Anakin.
 

Jdvn1 said:
When he tries to kill Obiwan, I'd take awa 'protagonist' status from him. When he turns on everyone, same thing.

And you said:I only mention it because your kiddies wouldn't be watching the slaughter. Like when Bambi's mother is killed, you don't see anything too gruesome.
Medea and Macbeth also killed plenty of people, she her children and her husband's new wife and the wife's father, he just about everyone he could. You don't lose protagonist status for being evil. That just makes you an antihero.
 

Rystil Arden said:
Medea and Macbeth also killed plenty of people, she her children and her husband's new wife and the wife's father, he just about everyone he could. You don't lose protagonist status for being evil. That just makes you an antihero.
Depends on how you see it. A protagonist could be defined as "a hero of a literary work" in which case an anti-hero wouldn't qualify. It could also be defined as "the central character in a literary work" in which case Anakin would be the protagonist.
 

Rystil Arden said:
He did kill the children offscreen. He drew a lightsabre on them and then when Obi-Wan and Yoda came in, they checked the children's corpses and saw that they had been slaughtered via lightsabre, then they found the perpetrator to be Anakin.
Although I'm amused by those people who live by the "if you don't see the corpse, he's not dead" rule.

Oh, and the corpses weren't children's corpses, but Jedi corpses.
 


Status
Not open for further replies.

Pets & Sidekicks

Remove ads

Top