Kemrain said:
That's pretty much it. Or at least a big part of it. Nervous nervous nervous. I have anxiety when I deal with commitment, and a PbP game is a lot more commitment than the Hive.
- Kemrain the Anxious.
Well, to answer the questions:
How does rolling work?
That's up to the GM. Some use online rollers, some trust players to roll their own dice honestly, some roll their own dice for everyone. Basically, it's not really something you have to worry about .
How do battles work?
Also up to the GM. He'll post what happens or what you see, and you'll post what you want to do. He'll explain it to everyone, though. Either you use an online roller and post the die result or you post your bonus and he'll roll for you.
I can't see what the GM sees, so wouldn't stuff be missed?
Well, this happens in any game you play, PbP or not. It's up to the GM to have clear descriptions, and if there's anything you feel is left out, feel free to ask. Alternately, some GMs post pictures or graphs so you can see where and how everything is laid out.
What about inflection? An all-text medium is very different.
True, this is also up to having clear descriptions. Players and GMs, when using text, can specify, though. There's a big difference between:
You hear steps running and around a corner comes a flash of oranges, whites, and yellows. A bouncy young halfling smiles at you with his green eyes, "Hi!" He runs toward you and wraps his arms around you, "It's been a long time since I've seen you!"
and
A large, dark gentleman turns a corner and his eyes widen as he realizes who it is. "Hello," he bellows, slowly approaching you. You see one of his hands slip toward where a weapon might be, "It has been a long time since I've seen you." He graps you and there is a knife at your throat.
Your Spot Check: 23 = success, Your Opposed Grapple Check: 17 = failure.