AD&D 2E Fey, but Old Skool

[Celebrim]

I'm looking for something where fey are in this world... mostly. I'm not looking for feywild as its own domain per se; nor am I looking for such a structured law/court thing as seems to be the norm. I'm looking for something mythic and mysterious, challenging mentally and role-playing wise - and I want to take some veteran players who are immersed into the classic D&D fey and pull them somewhere completely different.



More for ideas than mechanics.

So, do by "this world" do you mean "the (nominally) real world" or do you mean some fantasy gameable D&D world.

A lot of the things that I would have recommended to you involve living in Fairie or at least exploring it, but the immediate recommendation for something a bit numinous and fey is Dolmenwood. That's going to be different.

 

[Moving Pictures]

So, do by "this world" do you mean "the (nominally) real world" or do you mean some fantasy gameable D&D world.

A lot of the things that I would have recommended to you involve living in Fairie or at least exploring it, but the immediate recommendation for something a bit numinous and fey is Dolmenwood. That's going to be different.

Sorry, I meant "extant within the fantasy world I have created"

From a source, I can pull from Norse, Germanic, Celtic/Gaelic. So I can play with Sidhes, and I've already introduced the party to a chap with a thick brogue who explained that the sudden appearance of four-toed goblins (as opposed to the three-toed goblins people consider normal) is a function of the world returning to magic, and "the four-toed green people, they be touched by the wee folk."

 

[Celebrim]

Sorry, I meant "extant within the fantasy world I have created"

So does this world preexist your attempts to make it more fey? It's going to increase the difficulty of giving you advice because fitting into existing world building is challenging.

In addition to Swedish and British Isles centered folklore, may I recommend you look into Japanese folklore as well, as the Japanese conceptions of Kami and Yōkai fit well into classic notions of Western fairies. Right now I don't know what to recommend to you other than reading a lot of folklore, which you can start on Wikipedia until you figure out a more narrow focus.

 

[Fenris-77]

The fey in Into the Wyrd and Wild are quite wonderfully awful. Domlemwood also has a bunch of stuff that might be useful - the fey there are along the lines of what you're looking for. Personally, I've gotten a lot of mileage out of the novel Jonathan Strange and Mr. Norrell for fey imagery and the like.

 

[Willie the Duck]

I'm looking for something where fey are in this world... mostly. I'm not looking for feywild as its own domain per se; nor am I looking for such a structured law/court thing as seems to be the norm. I'm looking for something mythic and mysterious, challenging mentally and role-playing wise - and I want to take some veteran players who are immersed into the classic D&D fey and pull them somewhere completely different.

More for ideas than mechanics.

If the mechanics aren't the important part, have you considered porting parts of one of the White Wolf Faerie games?