Forgotten Realms Novels...which ones are good?

Of those that I've read recently, I like those by Paul Kemp, Lisa Smedman, Richard Lee Byers, Elaine Cunningham, and there's others I'm sure but they stick out most in my mind.

However, that said, while I adore his Realmslore, I avoid any novel written by Ed Greenwood like I'd avoid a broken glass cylinder marked with biohazard symbols and surrounded by a ring of twitching corpses.
 

log in or register to remove this ad




Ed Greenwood is a total hack

I'm surprised, people have reacted much more strongly to Greenwood than to Salvatore, the author that my tabletop group tends to dislike with a passion never before seen...

The books that I actually have copies of and have not yet read are Dissolution and Spellfire. I'm wary towards Dissolution, but that might be because I'm a little biased against Drow...but I'm willing to give 'em a chance, especially because I'm running City of the Spider Queen and I'm trying to get a little more background info...

Here is an exhaustive list of good FR novels:

Just because it's not great American literature doesn't mean it has no redeeming value whatsoever...how about "Which FR novels are good relative to other FR novels?"
 


MetalBard said:
It looks like the Waterdeep novel will be in that category when it comes out later this summer. It is written by Ed Greenwood and Elaine Cunningham.
Embarrassingly, I didn't even realize this was being released...but it'll be the first TSR/WotC paperback or hardcover that I'll have purchased in about 1,000 years!

I enjoyed all of Cunningham's work. If it has her name on it, I've liked it.

Greenwood is...quirky...but once you get into it, he's cool. And, of course, he created the Realms so it's "done right".

Salvatore is good, but not in huge doses at one time--I mean, he wrote about 30 books a week for a while there, and it all started to become a repetative blur. Have a saltine to clear the palette between his books (or at least trilogies).

I enjoyed the Harpers series. They're hopelessly out of print, but you might scrounge some up in a used book store. Many were hit & miss, but generally they were enjoyable.

I read Cormyr: A Novel and loved it.

Strangely, I never got into Troy Denning or Mel Odom. (Especially Odom.) Denning wrote the first book in the Harpers series (forgot the name of it...curse you, old age!) which was quite good, but from there he seemed to lose his appeal.

I did skim a few pages of Cordell's Lady of Poison in the book store. When I read a major character using the phrase "get a bead on the kidnappers" (and other abnormally anachronistic phrases like that) I immediately put the book back on the shelf. He won't be getting my money until he learns how to write. Great gaming rules-related writer, terrible fantasy fiction author....

I tried really hard to enjoy Kemp's Cale series, too, but I found that was also filled with many jarring anachronisms....

Oh well. I'm being picky, I mean they're being published by WotC, not Simon & Schuster or something.
 
Last edited:

Wraith Form said:
I did skim a few pages of Cordell's Lady of Poison in the book store. When I read a major character using the phrase "get a bead on the kidnappers" (and other abnormally anachronistic phrases like that) I immediately put the book back on the shelf. He won't be getting my money until he learns how to write. Great gaming rules-related writer, terrible fantasy fiction author....
A lot of words you wouldn't think twice about have similarly specific origins. They don't come from nowhere, so it's just a question of which etymologies you know and which you don't. Look at the word poison itself: does it bug you when a non-liquid poison is used, or a poison that isn't drunk? That isn't anachronism, it's just contemporary English, and it really doesn't have anything to do with being a good writer, fantasy or otherwise. (That said, he probably isn't a good writer anyway; I just disagree with the reason you give here.)
 

Wayside said:
(That said, he probably isn't a good writer anyway; I just disagree with the reason you give here.)


T.H. Lain....aka Bruce Cordell...

needs some help sorry to say.



I slogged thru Lady of Poison... ow... normally i can finish a FR book in about 2 evenings.... this one took weeks... i just couldn't do it. but i stuck to it until i finished....
 


Remove ads

Top