FR Novels-Which ones are good?

I just finished reading Temple Hill and while it was okay, I think I preferred the first book in the "Cities" series better - City of Ravens, I think it was called. And note that the word "series" is somewhat misleading there, as each book in the "series" is a standalone work about a different city.

Johnathan
 

log in or register to remove this ad


You know, I don't really understand the bias against the Forgotten Realms books sometimes. I've read R.E. Howard, Leiber, Brooks, Tolkien, Feist, and so on. Some I liked, some I didn't. They are generally better literature than the Forgotten Realms books, but I've read a few Forgotten Realms novels I really enjoyed.

It doesn't have to be the "best of the best" to enjoy it, after all. I still enjoy reading my old Marvel comics, for example. Anyway... I personally really enjoyed the Finders Stone Trilogy.

The books are the Azure Bonds, The Wyvernspur and The Saurials Song. I have enjoyed most everything I've read authored or co-authored by Jeff Grubb, so I'd also recommend Masquerades, Finders Bane, Tymoras Luck and Cormyr. Hope you enjoy them as much as I did.
 

I enjoyed most of the R.A. Salvatore novels. I also enjoyed the Avatar Trilogy. I also enjoyed the Finders Stone Trilogy. In general most of the FR novels I read I have enjoyed on some level. Many are comparable to summer action movies. Which I tend to enjoy on some level also. :)
 

If you are going to bother to read instead of watch TV or a movie, you might as well take advantage of reading's inherent advantages by reading something of real value. It you want to read, go for literature...
 

My favourites would definitely be the Song & Swords series by Elaine Cunningham.

Another series I enjoyed was the old Wyvernspur trilogy co-written by Jeff Grubb.

As for Salvatore and Drizzt, I liked the first two series - particularly the second and its depiction of the normal Drow, but gave up Salvatore and Drizzt midway through the novel Starless Night.

I also quite liked Prince of Lies + Crucible (although I wasnt really a fan of the trilogy that started it).
 


i think we've all heard the opinion that forgotten realms novels are not good literature, so if that's your only point in posting, maybe you shouldn't post... i'm not trying to be a jerk or anything, but you're not adding anything constructive to the discussion...
 

I've read most of the FR novels over the years - it's great for getting a feel for regions of FR, although, as many have stated, not great literature.

Others have mentioned some of the better novels - Elaine Cunningham, RA Salvatore (if you like his style - I usually do), Douglas Niles.

I just wanted to mention some to avoid.

I can't think of his name, but the guy who wrote the Volo novels - Brian Thomsen I think - they are terrible. They are rip-offs, with no original ideas, and just full of bad puns. "Once around the Realms" and "The mage in the iron mask".

Also the Pool of Radience series.

In fact, I'd suggest just avoiding anything written based on a computer game, except Azure Bonds.

Although I enjoyed the Drizzt novels, I didn't like the Cleric Quintet. Well, I loved the first one - it's an adventure where you can tell the characters are only about 1st level, and they are the type I usually like. The first novel was excellent, the second was good, the third ok, the fourth bad and the fifth terrible. The main characters' rise in power was far too fast, and by the end of the series I had a bad taste in my mouth for the whole thing.

Ed Greenwood is a great man, and his world is pretty good, IMO, but his novels.... well, I find that many times in his novels I have no clue as to what actually just happened. Spells are cast without a real explaination as to what they are, etc. I often find his novels leave me bewildered at points. This has been tempered when he writes with other authors (ie Cormyr and Death of a Dragon), but his solo stuff - not really my cup of tea.

Troy Denning is also a reasonable author, but he has one weakness. He won't let his characters go. He will start a new novel with a new set of characters, but somewhere in the novel some of his previous characters will appear. This can be charming, but not when it's so forced (the worst case - he killed off a character who then reappeared in other novels as a Seraphim(?) working for his god).

HTH

Duncan
 

Personally, I liked the first few drizzt books, but now i just buy new ones out of habit. Looking back, the Dark Elf trilogy was much better than the Icewind Dale triligy. IMPO the Paths of Darnkess quartet (the most recent itineration) really was not that great. The Legacy of the Drow Quartet was pretty good, I think, but since I read them all over the span of a single weekend, I'm not one to judge. Salvatore's new book looks good. Since its just about Drizzt, I am probably going to read it. After 14 books, I'm getting a little tired of the characters, though.

I think its just me, but i really feel like even there are a few thousand pages written about him, I still don't really have a sense of Drizzt, except that he is a drow, an outsider to society, missunderstood, and a do-gooder, but i dont quite know why he does good other than because he can, or some random BS like that... He really had no reason to risk his life so much.

On another note, Black Wolf was a good book. Its part of the Sembia Series, which chronicals the goings on of a rich noble family that has made a lot of enemies.
 

Remove ads

Top